By JIM SAUNDERS
THE NEWS SERVICE OF FLORIDA
THE CAPITAL, TALLAHASSEE, May 2, 2011….. The Florida Senate on Monday blew holes in a medical-malpractice bill backed by doctors and hospitals, as the House overwhelmingly approved the proposal across the Capitol.
Senators eliminated key parts of the bill, including one that would shield hospitals from liability if contracted physicians commit malpractice. Hospitals often contract with outside groups of physicians, such as radiologists, to provide care.
Critics said that part of the bill could hurt patients who go to hospitals and have little choice in their physicians. If a hospital is not liable --- and a doctor lacks malpractice insurance --- the patient might not be adequately compensated if malpractice occurs, they argued.
“It (deleting that part of the bill) provides recourse to patients who are injured in hospitals by physicians they don’t even know,’’ said Sen. Miguel Diaz de la Portilla, a Miami Republican who sponsored an amendment to remove the provision.
But bill sponsor Alan Hays, R-Umatilla, defended the proposal --- and rejected charges that legal immunity would give hospitals leeway to contract with cheaper, less-qualified physicians.
“The hospitals are there to provide quality medical care to the patients,’’ Hays said.
The Senate’s approval of three amendments was a victory for personal-injury lawyers, who have lobbied against the bill (SB 1590). The stripped-down bill continues to include new certification requirements for out-of-state expert witnesses who testify against doctors in malpractice cases.
Supporters argue those requirements would allow Florida to discipline experts who offer deceptive or fraudulent testimony --- a longtime complaint of doctors.
The Senate debate came at the same time the House voted 88-28 to approve its version of the bill (HB 479), which still has the proposals backed by doctors and hospitals. With the legislative session scheduled to end Friday, it is not clear how the chambers will reconcile the bills.
Rep. Bill Hager, R-Boca Raton, said legal reforms are needed because Florida continues to have a doctor shortage in some specialties.
“Let’s stand with our physicians, let’s stand with our hospitals,’’ Hager said.
But Rep. Richard Steinberg, D-Miami Beach, pointed to 2003 legislation that made it harder to sue for malpractice. He said lawmakers received promises that the measure would lower malpractice insurance rates, but doctors are still complaining about rates and seeking more limits on lawsuits.
“The issue is not that the patients have too many rights, the problem is there is not sufficient competition in the malpractice-insurance industry,’’ Steinberg said.
The House also voted 77-41 on Monday to approve a bill (HB 661) that would help shield nursing homes from lawsuits. Among other things, the bill would place a $300,000 cap on non-economic damages in wrongful-death lawsuits and make it harder to sue nursing homes for punitive damages.
But the fate of the nursing-home bill also is unclear, because a Senate version stalled in a committee.
Groups such as the Florida Medical Association and the Florida Hospital Association have lobbied for the medical-malpractice bill.
Along with the eliminating the proposed malpractice shield for hospitals, the Senate on Monday also deleted part of the bill that dealt with gathering patient information in malpractice cases.
The proposal called for allowing for what are known as “ex parte” communications between defense attorneys and physicians who treat patients after alleged malpractice. The talks could occur without the patients’ lawyers taking part.
But Sen. Anitere Flores, a Miami Republican who sponsored an amendment to eliminate the proposal, said defense attorneys should not be able to interview treating physicians without the patients’ lawyers being present.
“I don’t think it’s right for my medical history to be divulged without my knowledge,’’ Flores said.
But Hays said he was trying to fix a “grossly un-level playing field” that allows patients’ attorneys to have access to information from treating physicians.
Senators also eliminated part of the bill that called for making it harder to sue doctors over their failure to order supplemental diagnostic tests for patients.
Doctors argue that fear of lawsuits causes them to order unnecessary tests and perform “defensive medicine.” They say that drives up medical costs.
The bill proposed requiring patients to show by “clear and convincing evidence” that a doctor’s failure to order additional tests violated standards of care. That would make such cases harder to prove.
But the proposal’s critics said the state doesn’t need such a requirement.
“There’s no need to change the burden of proof,’’ said Sen. Rene Garcia, a Hialeah Republican who backed eliminating that part of the bill.
Spencer T. Kuvin Legal Blog - working at www.800goldlaw.com, the Law Offices of Craig Goldenfarb, P.A. as the Litigation Director/Lead Trial Attorney.
Tuesday, May 03, 2011
Justice Obtained for Spencer Kuvin's Client
For 19 years, Brian McQuillen survived against the odds, born with severely spastic cerebral palsy. He strived with determination to reach his full potential, but his efforts were cut short by an egregious medical mistake.
In mid December 2008, Brian was under the care of National Mentor Healthcare, a long term care facility for people with Brian's condition. While at school one day, his feeding tube came out. The nursing staff at National Mentor then re-inserted the tube too far into Brian, causing it to perforate the wall of his stomach. Unfortunately, none of his caregivers recognized their fatal mistake. Over the next several days, Brian's condition started to deteriorate and he displayed signs of concern, including cries for pain and fever. The medical professionals tasked with his care and well being did not recognize the severity of his condition until it was too late. The perforation of his stomach led to sepsis and no life saving measures could save Brian.
Spencer Kuvin, a partner at Cohen & Kuvin, LLC represented the McQuillen family in a case against Brian's caregivers and doctors. Kuvin stated, "It is a tragedy to see a young man who fought to survive in society, lose his battle due to the negligence of individuals whose responsibility was to ensure his care. We delivered justice on behalf of Brian McQuillen, and hope his story serves as a wake up call to all caregivers to pay attention to their patients, as it could be the difference between life and death."
http://www.cohenkuvin.com/
stk@cohenkuvin.com
561-665-8020
In mid December 2008, Brian was under the care of National Mentor Healthcare, a long term care facility for people with Brian's condition. While at school one day, his feeding tube came out. The nursing staff at National Mentor then re-inserted the tube too far into Brian, causing it to perforate the wall of his stomach. Unfortunately, none of his caregivers recognized their fatal mistake. Over the next several days, Brian's condition started to deteriorate and he displayed signs of concern, including cries for pain and fever. The medical professionals tasked with his care and well being did not recognize the severity of his condition until it was too late. The perforation of his stomach led to sepsis and no life saving measures could save Brian.
Spencer Kuvin, a partner at Cohen & Kuvin, LLC represented the McQuillen family in a case against Brian's caregivers and doctors. Kuvin stated, "It is a tragedy to see a young man who fought to survive in society, lose his battle due to the negligence of individuals whose responsibility was to ensure his care. We delivered justice on behalf of Brian McQuillen, and hope his story serves as a wake up call to all caregivers to pay attention to their patients, as it could be the difference between life and death."
http://www.cohenkuvin.com/
stk@cohenkuvin.com
561-665-8020
The Court Packing Plan is Dead!
This evening the Senate took up and passed an amendment to HJR 7111 that gutted House Speaker Dean Cannon’s legislative assault on our fair and impartial courts. The amendment, co-sponsored by ten Republican Senators, eliminated the proposal to split the Supreme Court into two divisions and give the Governor full reign to select justices. It also did away with the proposal to set court funding at 2.25% of General Revenue, a move that would have potentially locked the judicial branch into perpetual underfunding.
Please take time to contact the lawmakers who sponsored this amendment, and stood strong against extreme pressure from leadership to go along with Cannon’s court “reform” package. To see the list of sponsors and read the amendment, go to http://www.flsenate.gov/Session/Bill/2011/7111/Amendment/289464/HTML
The House has reportedly agreed to the amended proposal. That vote will come later this week. The measures that remain in the bill include Senate confirmation of appellate court judicial appointments and a lowering of the threshold for the legislature to over-rule a court rule of procedure (to 50% instead of 2/3’s, with a requirement for the legislature to provide policy direction for any rule they overturn). The amended joint resolution would also give the Speaker of the House access to JQC investigative files for potential impeachment proceedings. If passed by the House, the proposal will go on the ballot in the 2012 general election.
While no bill would have been our first choice – this is a major victory. We will continue to watch the JNC bill which is still sitting on the special order calendar, although all indications are it will not move forward.
Links to lawmaker contact information are available on our website, http://www.fairandimpartial.com/
Thank goodness for the hard work of all the advocates for justice that worked tirelessly to defeat this bad bill. Hopefully this will show the legislature of Florida, along with the Governer, that they cannot run rough shod over the rights of Florida citizens. The separation of powers is at risk in Florida, and the attorneys at Cohen & Kuvin are working hard to protect your rights against this unlawful intrusion by the legislative and executive branch.
Spencer T. Kuvin
Cohen Kuvin
skuvin@cohenkuvin.com
Please take time to contact the lawmakers who sponsored this amendment, and stood strong against extreme pressure from leadership to go along with Cannon’s court “reform” package. To see the list of sponsors and read the amendment, go to http://www.flsenate.gov/Session/Bill/2011/7111/Amendment/289464/HTML
The House has reportedly agreed to the amended proposal. That vote will come later this week. The measures that remain in the bill include Senate confirmation of appellate court judicial appointments and a lowering of the threshold for the legislature to over-rule a court rule of procedure (to 50% instead of 2/3’s, with a requirement for the legislature to provide policy direction for any rule they overturn). The amended joint resolution would also give the Speaker of the House access to JQC investigative files for potential impeachment proceedings. If passed by the House, the proposal will go on the ballot in the 2012 general election.
While no bill would have been our first choice – this is a major victory. We will continue to watch the JNC bill which is still sitting on the special order calendar, although all indications are it will not move forward.
Links to lawmaker contact information are available on our website, http://www.fairandimpartial.com/
Thank goodness for the hard work of all the advocates for justice that worked tirelessly to defeat this bad bill. Hopefully this will show the legislature of Florida, along with the Governer, that they cannot run rough shod over the rights of Florida citizens. The separation of powers is at risk in Florida, and the attorneys at Cohen & Kuvin are working hard to protect your rights against this unlawful intrusion by the legislative and executive branch.
Spencer T. Kuvin
Cohen Kuvin
skuvin@cohenkuvin.com
Sunday, May 01, 2011
Florida Assisted Living Facilities Are A Disaster
SOURCE: MIAMI HERALD: ONCE SOURCE OF PRIDE, NOW SCENE OF NEGLECT
For more than a decade, Bruce Hall ran his assisted-living facility in Florida’s Panhandle like a prison camp.
He punished his disabled residents by refusing to give them food and drugs. He threatened them with a stick. He doped them with powerful tranquilizers, and when they broke his rules, he beat them — sending at least one to the hospital.
“The conditions in the facility are not fit even for a dog,” one caller told state agents.
When Florida regulators confronted Hall in 2004 over a litany of abuses at his facility in the rolling hills of Washington County, they said he chased them from the premises while railing against government intrusion.
Under state law, regulators could have shut down Sunshine Acres Loving Care or suspended the home’s license, but they did neither. Instead, they ordered the 50-year-old Hall to see a therapist for his anger and to promise not to use “any weapon or object” on his residents — allowing him to keep his doors open for five more years.
In that time, Hall went on to break nearly every provision of Florida’s assisted-living law: He threw a woman to the ground, and forced her to sleep on a box spring for six days after she urinated on her covers. Though the temperature outside reached 100 degrees, he forced his residents to live without air conditioning. And during a critical overnight shift, he fell asleep on the job while a 71-year-old woman with mental illness wandered from her bed, walked out the door and drowned in a nearby pond.
In a state where tens of thousands reside in assisted-living facilities, the case of Hall’s Sunshine Acres represents everything that has gone wrong with homes once considered the pride of Florida.
Created more than a quarter-century ago, ALFs were established in landmark legislation to provide shelter and sweeping protections to some of the state’s most vulnerable citizens: the elderly and mentally ill.
Tragedies revealed
But a Miami Herald investigation found that the safeguards once hailed as the most progressive in the nation have been ignored in a string of tragedies never before revealed to the public.
In Kendall, a 74-year-old woman was bound for more than six hours, the restraints pulled so tightly they ripped into her skin and killed her.
In Hialeah, a 71-year-old man with mental illness died from burns after he was left in a bathtub filled with scalding water.
In Clearwater, a 75-year-old Alzheimer’s patient was torn apart by an alligator after he wandered from his assisted-living facility for the fourth time.
The deaths highlight critical breakdowns in a state enforcement system that has left thousands of people to fend for themselves in dangerous and decrepit conditions.
The Miami Herald found that the Agency for Health Care Administration, which oversees the state’s 2,850 assisted-living facilities, has failed to monitor shoddy operators, investigate dangerous practices or shut down the worst offenders.
Time and again, the agency was alerted by police and its own inspectors to caretakers depriving residents of the most basic needs — food, water and protection — but didn’t take action.
When AHCA agents were forced to end their inspection of Sunshine Acres in 2008 because of threats by the owner — the second time in four years — the agency didn’t return for eight months.
By the time agents went back, they found a resident eating from a filthy food bin, four inches of dirt on the floor of a dorm room and six residents drugged on tranquilizers without doctors’ orders.
“Lord help us all if he gets mad,” one resident told state regulators about the owner.
Frustrated over the state’s inability to close Sunshine Acres, neighbors began gathering at the local fire station to launch a plan to prompt regulators to act.
“It took the whole damn neighborhood,” said Dewayne Anderson, 55, who lives next door to the home.
A representative of the group fired off several e-mails to AHCA, demanding the state enforce its laws and pointing out a litany of problems created by the facility.
After 14 years of running the home and racking up more than 100 violations, Hall was finally told by AHCA to sell Sunshine Acres. But once again, regulators struck another deal: Hall was given a year to find a buyer.
Failure to protect
The Miami Herald spent a year examining thousands of state inspections, police reports, court cases, autopsy files, e-mails, death certificates and conducting dozens of interviews with operators and residents across the state.
Reporters found that as the ranks of assisted-living facilities grew to make room for Florida’s booming elderly population, the state failed to protect the people it was meant to serve.
For example:
• Nearly once a month, residents die from abuse and neglect — with some caretakers even altering and forging records to conceal evidence — but law enforcement agencies almost never make arrests.
• Homes are routinely caught using illegal restraints — including powerful tranquilizers, locked closets and ropes — but the state rarely if ever punishes them.
• State regulators could have shut down 70 homes in the past two years for a host of severe violations — including neglect and abuse by caretakers — but in the end, closed just seven.
• While the number of new homes has exploded across the state — 550 in the past five years — the state has dropped critical inspections by 33 percent, allowing some of the worst facilities to stay open.
• Though the state has the power to impose fines on homes that break the law, the penalties are routinely decreased, delayed or dropped altogether.
• The state’s lack of enforcement has prompted other government agencies to cut off funding and in some cases refuse to send clients to live in homes AHCA won’t close.
For example, the Miami-Dade Court’s mental health project won’t send clients to All America ACLF, where Angel Joglar, a 71-year-old man with schizophrenia, was scalded in a bathtub after his caretaker left him alone in 2006, dying from the burns weeks later.
Since his death, AHCA has cited the home for at least 100 violations — including untrained staff failing to stop residents from beating each other with two-by-fours.
After Hillandale ALF was caught locking residents with mental illness in a closet to punish them — along with a host of other violations — the state Agency for Persons with Disabilities cut off hundreds of thousands of dollars it was sending to the home in Pasco County.
Both facilities are still licensed by AHCA.
AHCA, which is empowered with tough tools to enforce the law, said its goal is to get facilities to obey the rules — and imposing fines or other penalties are secondary measures.
Reluctant to punish
The agency, which would only respond to questions in writing, said pushing to revoke a home’s license is a “very harsh penalty” used as a last resort. Before doing so, it considers several issues, including the immediate danger to residents and the ability to relocate them to a new home.
Each penalty is considered based on “unique circumstances,” and other actions are explored “prior to the most serious sanction of revocation,” the agency wrote.
However, The Miami Herald found that AHCA repeatedly catches homes breaking the law but fails to act, at times with dire consequences.
At Hampton Court in Haines City, regulators caught caretakers 11 times in the past five years failing to give out medication, not keeping records of drugs given to residents and falsifying records to show drugs had been given when they hadn’t. The state could have imposed emergency measures, including a ban on new residents until the home cleaned up its practices, but never did.
Eventually, someone died.
Norman Dube, a 74-year-old retired postal worker suffering from diabetes and depression, went 13 days last March without crucial antibiotics — and several days without food or water. As he slipped into unconsciousness, he began telling people “things were crawling on his skin,” a state report said.
At the same time, the home failed to tell his doctor he wasn’t getting his drugs, which included blood pressure medications and anti-psychotics.
The next month, Dube died. A state Department of Children & Families investigation concluded the home committed medical neglect.
But the problems didn’t end. On June 25, two months later, state agents returned to the home and found two more residents languishing without their medication, despite doctor’s orders.
The home promised to correct the problems, but in August it happened again — this time, three more residents were not getting their drugs. Two months ago, the facility was taken over by a new owner.
When it comes to imposing fines, AHCA said it doesn’t routinely drop or reduce them, saying it only lowered fines by 7 percent this fiscal year.
But an analysis shows the agency rarely asks for what’s allowed by law. Consider: In 2009 — the same year lawmakers expanded AHCA’s power to levy fines — the agency could have imposed more than $6 million, but took in just $650,000.
Homes of horror
The law that empowered the state to discipline homes was passed three decades ago in response to a growing crisis: Elderly people moving to Florida were ending up in group homes run by abusive caretakers.
The state passed a celebrated Residents Bill of Rights in 1980 — championed by veteran Miami congressman Claude Pepper — pledging that people in those homes would be protected and treated with dignity.
The homes would shelter two of the state’s fastest-growing groups — the elderly and mentally ill — and at the same time offer an alternative to nursing homes.
Now, people who needed help with everyday chores but didn’t require 24-hour nursing care could live independently.
But as the industry boomed, the state began a series of crucial moves that would change the way it regulated homes.
Instead of inspecting ALFs once a year like most large states — including Arizona, Texas, Pennsylvania, North Carolina and Illinois — Florida cut inspections to just once every two years.
The same trend took place with investigations of serious incidents like deaths and injuries — known as adverse incidents — which were slashed by 90 percent between 2002 and 2008.
Regulators never investigated Isabel Adult Care III after the owner reported that Aurora Navas, an 85-year-old grandmother with dementia, had quietly wandered from the Miami-Dade home and drowned in a pond in the backyard in 2008.
“Her lack of ability to find her way back caused her accidental death,” wrote the home’s administrator, Isabel Lopez, in a report to AHCA. “We found that all procedures were followed. The facility has door alarms, proper door locks, and a fenced backyard.”
But records show that if regulators had carried out what was once a routine exercise, they would have found just the opposite: The door alarm and video cameras weren’t working, the back gate was unlocked and an attendant had fallen asleep, Miami-Dade police records show.
Navas, who had a history of wandering, was found floating in 18 inches of water, clad only in her lavender sleeping gown, a blue slipper on the ground nearby.
To this day, Alfredo Navas says he’s enraged the state never investigated his mother’s death at the quiet suburban home just north of Kendall.
“You don’t follow up when it comes to human beings who are supposed to be watching other human beings. They get nothing,” said Navas, 59, adding that his mother was afraid of water most of her life. “The safeguards you thought in place weren’t in place.”
In an interview, Lopez said she was ordered by fire inspectors to remove the locks from the rear door. But county records show that was not the case: Inspectors simply told her to get new locks.
Cases skyrocket
While inspections of homes were dropping across the state, another troubling trend was under way that would set new records.
The state Department of Elder Affairs ombudsman program was uncovering more cases of abuse and neglect than it had seen in the last three decades, with numbers doubling in the past five years.
Though the program sends its findings to AHCA, regulators failed to investigate the vast majority of the cases, records show. In fact, a state audit in 2008 found that AHCA couldn’t locate two-thirds of the complaints sent to the agency.
“It’s baffling to me,” said Brian Lee, the ombudsman program’s past director. “We find things, and it’s like, how did they not see the same things?”
Even when AHCA does find problems — including people dying from abuse and medical neglect — it rarely moves to close homes, allowing the same dangerous violations to turn up again.
Though Briarwood Manor has been the target of more than 1,200 police and rescue calls in the past five years — with residents stabbing, fighting and suffering psychiatric breakdowns — the Broward County facility has been allowed to stay open.
The drab, stuccoed home in the heart of Lauderhill has been slapped with scores of violations by AHCA — 100 in the past five years — including an episode in which a man slashed his roommate with a knife during a crack binge while the night caretaker was nowhere to be found. Twice in the past five years, the state could have revoked or suspended the home’s license, but did neither.
Instead, AHCA allowed Briarwood to operate for four years while it owed massive fines that peaked at more than $370,000, with AHCA eventually agreeing to reduce the amount by 74 percent in 2008.
Briarwood is among the hundreds of ALFs that opened their doors in the past decade, driven by the closing of state mental health institutions.
But as the industry boomed, AHCA failed to keep up with the growth, with state agents taking longer to respond to dangerous breakdowns. A Miami Herald analysis shows it took inspectors an average of 37 days to complete complaint investigations in 2009, 10 days longer than five years earlier.
At least five times, other agencies were forced to take the lead in shutting down homes when AHCA didn’t act.
One Hardee County sheriff’s detective said he was unable to prod AHCA to shut down Southern Oaks Retirement Center last year after he found residents sleeping on torn, urine-soaked mattresses surrounded by moldy, cracked walls and boarded-up windows.
Though AHCA had turned up the same hazards at the Central Florida home for eight years — including just a month earlier — the facility stayed open until fire officials ordered the evacuation of all 49 residents on June 22, 2010.
Not until the home made critical repairs five weeks later was the order lifted.
For Rosalie Manor, it was a longer battle.
For years, Pinellas County sheriff’s deputies had been forced to round up dozens of residents with mental illnesses found wandering the small town of Dunedin, breaking into a school and homes, and shoplifting from businesses.
When deputies finally investigated, they found Rosalie Manor owner Erik Anderson had placed a 53-year-old man just released from a psychiatric ward in charge of dispensing powerful psychotropic drugs to others in the home.
When two residents suffered breakdowns after not getting their crucial medications, detectives sent a warning to AHCA: Shut the place down.
But regulators dropped the case a month later, citing a lack of evidence — prompting an angry response from Sgt. J. Michael Daily, who slammed AHCA for its “inability to take action on this and other valid complaints at Rosalie Manor,” records show.
During the next two months, deputies joined prosecutors in a rare effort to close the 34-bed facility.
Detectives brought forward reams of paperwork in 2006 detailing abuse and neglect inside the cluster of cottages near downtown Dunedin — including violations turned up by AHCA year after year.
They found Anderson had covered up crucial evidence in death investigations of the home’s residents.
In one case in 2003, he threatened to fire any employee who called police after finding blood splattered on the walls of a 72-year-old man’s bedroom and a suicide note on the dresser.
In 2005, he drove a male resident with a criminal history to a pharmacy to fill a prescription for powerful narcotics, but failed to collect the drugs from the man, who then fed them to a 20-year-old female resident with mental illness. She was then raped by the man and died in her bedroom from an overdose.
Administrator charged
In the end, prosecutors charged Anderson, 60, with neglect, witness tampering and falsifying medical records. He pleaded guilty and surrendered his ALF license. His sentence: probation.
Caretaker Mary Pressley, 47, who worked at Rosalie for nearly a decade, said she couldn’t understand why AHCA never moved to close the home. “I don’t know how he got away with what he did,” she said.
Since 2005, Rosalie was among more than 40 homes found to be placing residents in immediate danger — the most serious breach of Florida’s ALF law — with a quarter of the homes going on to do it again.
Even after AHCA inspectors warned their own agency that Bruce Hall was running a dangerous facility in 2004, he was allowed to renew his license and expand the home to make room for eight more beds.
It was the third time the troubled facility was granted a renewal by AHCA, despite breaking the state’s ALF law 51 times.
The next year, Hall fell asleep on night watch duty just long enough for 71-year-old Elnora Shuler to wander out the door with her baby doll and slip into a pond on the premises.
When AHCA investigators asked Hall why the fence around the pond was only half finished, an inspection report states he responded: “My complacency is the reason… I knew I’d find [Shuler] down there in that pond someday.”
When agents visited the ramshackle 52-bed home in North Florida to investigate a tip that Hall threatened residents with a gun, he flew into a rage, referring to the residents as “deranged, mental retarded sons of bitches,” while lashing out at state agents, reports showed.
In the end, inspectors Patty McIntire and Kara Cowart, along with a Washington County sheriff’s deputy, left the property without completing their investigation, citing “safety concerns.”
For his tirade, Hall was fined $1,756 and ordered to visit a therapist because of his anger. But just 17 days later, he shoved a woman diagnosed with mental retardation to the ground, sending her to the hospital with a sprained ankle and cuts on her arm, elbow, knee and shin.
Hall told regulators he was protecting his wife after the resident grabbed her arm, but state agents cited him for abuse.
In an interview with The Miami Herald, Hall said regulators were “bureaucrats” who didn’t understand the challenges of dealing with people with mental disabilities — and that he had a right to impose force on residents when they got unruly.
“If one of them jumps on you and you got to beat the hell out of them to get them off you, then you get held responsible,” he said. “I’m the damn culprit that’s the bad guy in all this?”
He blamed residents and his neighbors for bringing unwarranted scrutiny to the facility.
“These mentally handicapped residents, they know the game,” he said. “They will play you. They are of the system, they know the system — just like a prisoner. They know what they can get away with.”
He said if he hadn’t imposed discipline on his residents, they would have taken control of the facility. “They’re going to realize they can continue to treat you like a dog,” he said.
During a state inspection in 2006, 14 residents at Sunshine Acres refused to give their names to AHCA agents, saying they feared retaliation.
Between 2007 and 2008, five employees quit their jobs, saying they were tired of the abuse at the home, state reports show.
During that same period, sheriff’s deputies and rescue workers were called to the home more than 400 times for, among other things, fights between residents and people suffering psychiatric breakdowns.
“It was like a damn nightmare,” said Dewayne Anderson, a next-door neighbor who joined the community coalition to close the home.
In 2008, Hall ran AHCA agents off the premises a second time after berating an elderly female resident who was trying to talk privately to them.
Hall “dropped to his knees in front of the resident” and with “flushed face, clenched jaw, rapid, loud speech, flaying [flying] arms,” he said he was throwing her out for complaining about him.
“The survey was discontinued at this point due to a fear for the safety of the surveyors,” inspectors wrote.
After the event, the state threatened to kick Hall out of the business.
In April, agents sent a letter saying Sunshine Acres’ license would not be renewed. But it was. In October, regulators told Hall to get out — but once again, bargained the punishment down, giving him a year to sell the troubled home.
Through it all, agents continued to find more problems: Six residents were illegally given powerful drugs known as “chemical restraints,” designed to keep them under control — without a doctor’s consent, agents wrote.
Finally, after more than 115 citations from AHCA, Hall sold the home in September 2009 — still holding the mortgage in a deal that will earn him $1.1 million during the next 10 years.
Wandering resident meets a grisly end
By MICHAEL SALLAH, ROB BARRY and CAROL MARBIN MILLER
msallah@MiamiHerald.com
Caretakers at the Beckett Lake Lodge assisted living facility struggled to keep track of Walter Stowman Cox.
The 75-year-old man with dementia was once found in bank lobby after wandering from his Pinellas County ALF. Months later, he wandered into a nearby condo complex and had to be escorted back.
But the last time he left Beckett Lake Lodge — his home for more than a year — he never returned.
The former Episcopal priest and social worker was found a week later floating face down in a thatch of cattails in a nearby lake, his body ripped apart by alligators.
His gruesome death in 2004 led to an investigation by the Agency for Health Care Administration, which turned up several violations, including a citation for failing to keep track of Cox’s whereabouts. But in the end, no fines were imposed and no penalties issued in the death of the elderly grandfather.
AHCA said the home committed a minor infraction that didn’t call for a penalty. But records show AHCA initially slapped the home with a serious violation for putting Cox in danger — punishable by a $5,000 fine. The agency later agreed to lower the severity of the violation.
In the year before Cox died, records show he was growing confused, with a psychologist noting the Air Force veteran was suffering from “memory impairment” and in need of an anti-anxiety drug. Though Beckett Lake Lodge had a section for people with dementia — where residents are more closely monitored — Cox was never placed in the ward.
The home’s director of care, Audrey Malin, later said in a deposition she didn’t think he should have been allowed to leave the facility “because I would already have known that there were risks.”
Home administrator Michael Payne declined to talk about the death.
Cox had wandered at least three times, but his daughter, Sharon Sandoval, said no one from the home told her — including one episode seven months before he died when police had to conduct a nighttime search for him. Had she known, she said, she would have asked he be placed in the more secure setting.
The day before Cox wandered into the woods for the last time, he was found confused outside a nearby development. The next day, when he wanted to go for a walk, the home sent an aide to watch him. But Cox soon bolted into the woods, and the aide, who wasn’t carrying a cellphone, didn’t follow, returning to the facility before calling rescue workers.
After a week of searching, law enforcement officers on an airboat found Cox’s partially clothed body in four feet of water on the edge of Harbor Lake, his upper torso ripped by alligator bites and both arms missing.
In the year before his death, regulators cited the home twice for not keeping key medical records, including doctor’s orders detailing the specific care each resident was supposed to receive. In fact, the home didn’t complete those documents for Cox until he’d been missing four days, records show.
After initially finding the home had lost track of Cox when he ran into the woods, AHCA reversed its decision, saying workers at the home “were aware of the whereabouts,” said Shelisha Coleman, an agency spokesperson. But records show no one knew where Cox was until police pulled his badly mauled body from the water seven days later.
Sandoval, 52, whose family recently settled a lawsuit with the home for an undisclosed amount, said she was haunted by whether her father was still alive when his body was attacked by the alligator.
“I kept going around and around in my head all the different possibilities,” she said. “I was just driving myself crazy. Finally, I just came to the conclusion that I will never know.
”
A history of violence ends in fiery rampage
By CAROL MARBIN MILLER, ROB BARRY AND MICHAEL SALLAH
cmarbin@MiamiHerald.com
Pedro Sanchez set his bed on fire with a red disposable lighter. Then, clutching a large, jagged rock, he struck the frail, elderly people who tried to flee the deadly inferno.
“Aqui vamos a morir todos!” witnesses said Sanchez shouted as he beat a 55-year-old man in a wheelchair. “We are all going to die here.”
Though five residents of the K&K Adult Care Center in Miami escaped the Oct. 1, 2005, blaze, 78-year-old Graciela Labastilla would succumb to the toxic fumes.
In the coming days, state agents turned up evidence that the facility had failed to safeguard its elderly and disabled residents, leaving a violent man with a criminal past to prey on vulnerable adults.
Just days before he ignited the fire, Sanchez was allowed back to the home after being committed to a psychiatric ward for threatening a resident and throwing a rock into a neighbor’s house.
The Agency for Health Care Administration determined the home did not protect the residents, but no penalty was ever imposed.
In addition, Miami-Dade fire officials said the fact that hurricane shutters were fastened to the home’s windows — with no impending storms — increased the danger to the residents.
The only person charged in the death of the grandmother of 10 was Sanchez — arrested for arson and homicide — who remains in Atlantic Shores State Hospital, incompetent to stand trial.
Two weeks before the blaze, Sanchez had erupted in anger after a staff member tried to stop him from leaving the home.
The 78-year-old, who was on felony probation for carrying a concealed weapon before moving into the home, threw a rock at a neighbor’s house and threatened to hit caretakers with a stick, witnesses said.
Miami-Dade police officers finally subdued him, taking him to Palmetto General Hospital’s psychiatric ward, where he stayed for 10 days before returning to the ALF.
Over the following days, resident Omar Buttari said Sanchez repeatedly threatened “to burn the place down.”
On Oct. 1, 2005, a caretaker awoke before dawn to a wailing fire alarm. Griselda Cruz, 52, said she grabbed a fire extinguisher, but couldn’t put out the flames. Sanchez, she told detectives, was trying to keep residents from leaving by slamming their bedroom doors and screaming that everyone was going to die.
“Que has hecho?” she asked Sanchez after noticing his bed engulfed in flames. “What have you done?”
The five residents could escape only through the front and back doors because the home had not removed the aluminum shutters barricading the windows. As Cruz tried to help the elderly residents toward the front door, Sanchez struck her in the mouth with the rock. He beat Buttari on the head.
Rescue workers found Labastilla sprawled on the floor and took her to Memorial Hospital Miramar, where she died two days later of carbon monoxide toxicity.
The rock was still in Sanchez’s pocket when police confronted him down the street.
Police estimated the damage at $200,000, and K&K was shut down for good by its owner.
Family members said they were stunned to learn their mother, a retired seamstress who owned a small business in Hialeah, was living in a home with a convicted felon who had been threatening residents for days.
Under Florida law, homes are supposed to evaluate residents to determine whether they are appropriate for placement in their facilities.
“I didn’t know there was anybody like Pedro Sanchez in there,” said the victim’s son, Manny Labastilla. “If you have someone who has that type or degree of mental illness to the point where he’s going to threaten a person, he should be at a different type of facility.”
KEY EVENTS IN ALF LAW
1975
• Landmark U.S. Supreme Court decision bans states from confining citizens to institutions if they are non-dangerous and capable of living by themselves or with relatives — leading to the closing of psychiatric facilities and leaving a large number of people in need of housing.
• Licensing of Adult Congregate Living Facilities in Florida begins, with passage of state law setting basic standards for people living in boarding-house settings with a staff to prepare meals and manage medications for residents.
1980
• The Florida Legislature passes the first comprehensive regulations for ACLFs, establishing licensing standards, a fraud enforcement unit to protect Medicaid funds, and a bill of rights for group-home residents.
1981
• Federal legislation creates a program allowing states to use long-term care money available through Medicaid to pay for residents’ room and board at group homes.
1982
Amendments are passed in Florida drawing clear distinctions between nursing homes and assisted-living facilities, where people need help with everyday chores but not 24-hour nursing care.
1987
• The state has 1,400 assisted-living facilities housing 42,000 people.
1990
Florida’s population nearly doubles between 1970 and 1990 — from 6.7 million to 12.9 million — creating waves of elderly and disabled people in need of housing and care.
1991
• The creation of the Florida Department of Elder Affairs with Bentley Lipscomb as the director. One of the agency’s goals: protect the rights of the elderly in assisted-living facilities and nursing homes.
1992
• Agency for Health Care Administration becomes chief regulator of ACLFs after splitting from the state Department of Health and Rehabilitative Services.
• There are now 1,568 ACLFs throughout the state.
1993
• The Florida Legislature refuses to increase funding for inspections of ACLFs despite their growth across the state. As a result, inspections are reduced from once a year to once every two years.
1995
• The state renames Adult Congregate Living Facilities as Assisted Living Facilities (ALFs), an emerging housing model that’s expected to surpass nursing homes as the signature facilities for elderly and mentally ill people.
• A newly revamped Elder Abuse Law in the Florida Legislature makes it easier for prosecutors to push for felonies against people who abuse or exploit elderly and disabled people.
1997
• The state adopts a law requiring ALFs housing people with mental illness to obtain a special license. It also requires facilities that care for people with Alzheimer’s disease and other disorders to meet standards of operation, including requirements that homes with 17 or more residents have an awake staff member on duty at all hours, and that all employees have a minimum level of training.
• The state is now home to 1,922 ALFs.
1999
Operation Spot Check: Attorney General Bob Butterworth expands a program that draws together multiple agencies to carry out surprise inspections of troubled homes that received Medicaid funding. The agencies include the state attorney general’s Medicaid Fraud Control Unit, AHCA, the Department of Children & Families, Florida’s Long Term Care Ombudsman Council, state attorneys, and local fire and code inspectors. The goal: rooting out neglect and abuse.
2000
• Florida now has 2,305 ALFs.
2001
• State legislators pass sweeping tort reforms that slash the amount of insurance ALF owners are required to carry, set limits on lawsuits — making it more difficult for lawyers to sue facilities — and end the practice of awarding attorneys’ fees in cases that do not involve death or serious injury.
• The state House of Representatives passes a bill that
2008
Florida adopts new laws raising the penalty for aggravated abuse of elderly and disabled people to a first-degree felony.
2010
The state now has 2,850 ALFs housing more than 80,000 people.
Toxic sore fatally undetected
Already heartbroken by his wife’s deterioration through Alzheimer’s, Theodore Archer then watched her die needlessly from an ignored poisonous sore.
Theodore and Dorothy Archer retired to sleepy Hernando County in 1981, but never really settled down. For the next 20 years, the Archers did the Lord’s work, driving a recreational vehicle from Florida to Canada, California to Maine, renovating churches with a group called Servants on Wheels.
It was the sudden onset of Alzheimer’s disease that finally slowed Dorothy Archer.
Unable to cope with his wife’s forgetfulness and agitation, Theodore Archer moved her to a nearby assisted-living facility called Edwinola Manor in late 2008. There, he thought, she would get the care and service she had given so selflessly as a church outreach worker.
Instead, nurses failed to treat a gaping pressure sore on her lower back that filled her body with raging toxins.
“There is no valid reason for such a wound developing undetected in an ALF resident,” wrote Tim McClain, a registered nurse who investigated the case for the state Department of Children & Families.
Archer, 90, was not the first Edwinola resident to fall victim to shoddy care.
In April 2008, Carmen DeArmas was hospitalized with a rotting, oozing foot, requiring immediate surgery. Family members told investigators the injury was so bad, the 79-year-old woman’s sock was “embedded into the skin,” a DCF report says.
Two months later, Edwinola administrators told the Agency for Health Care Administration they had retrained workers to better recognize and report signs that residents’ health had deteriorated.
But in October that year more problems emerged: AHCA found the home had failed to keep records on three more residents whose health had deteriorated — including one whose pressure sore was severe enough to force a hospital stay.
Once again, Edwinola administrators submitted a detailed plan for doing better.
The plan had just been put in place when Dorothy Archer was admitted to the retirement home, diagnosed with acute psychosis — the result of a quickly progressing case of dementia.
The Archers had been inseparable for 37 years, living in the Philippines, Hawaii, South Africa, Panama, Virginia and a host of other places where Theodore’s second career as a combustion engineer took him.
“We were always together,’’ Theodore Archer said. “Everywhere I went, she was with me.’’
The couple had planned to grow old together — and die together.
But the retired naval chief petty officer — who survived the sinking of the USS Hornet at the Pacific battle of Santa Cruz in 1942 — was no match for his wife’s Alzheimer’s.
Confused and agitated, Archer had been hospitalized under Florida’s involuntary commitment law when a neighbor suggested Edwinola, a 170-bed home in Dade City, just north of Tampa Bay. Archer said he visited his wife every day — usually more than once.
Medical notes suggest Archer was faring well in the facility until March, when nurses feared a raspy cough might be the first signs of pneumonia.
When Archer was sent to a nearby hospital for treatment, the home’s notes documented only a “small” skin lesion, described two days earlier as a “red area” on her lower back.
But doctors immediately said the home’s description of the wound was far from accurate. The festering sore, as large as a grapefruit, had become so infected it had turned black — and her kidney was failing, said Dr. Keith Rosenbach at Pasco Regional Medical Center.
“The poison is all throughout her body. There’s no way I can save her,’’ her husband said he was told by a doctor.
Archer was transferred to a local hospice. Aides cleaned her, and put on a crisp new gown. Within 30 minutes, she was dead.
After her death in 2009, state investigators questioned the home’s treatment of Archer’s blackened sore.
“It is obvious that ALF staff should have noticed the buttock wound,’’ McClain, the DCF nurse, wrote. “It is also clear that there was a serious systemic failure at the ALF.’’ Archer, he concluded, “was inadequately supervised and medically neglected.”
Janice Merrill, an Orlando attorney who represents Edwinola, declined to comment, citing ongoing litigation.
Even after Archer died, the problems at Edwinola continued.
A month after her death, a woman was hospitalized with bruises on her arm, wrist, chest and buttocks. Doctors discovered she had been given so high a dose of blood-thinners that she needed several transfusions. She also had been given three pain patches — triple the dose prescribed by her doctor.
The woman, a DCF investigator wrote, had been “overmedicated to the point of losing consciousness.’’
During the investigation, the home’s director of nursing resigned. The facility once again told state agents it had “incorporated new safety measures and training to prevent recurrence,” DCF records show.
But in November 2010, regulators found more breakdowns — this time, after relatives complained a resident of the home was “acting strangely and no one knew why.” When inspectors showed up, they found the home had failed to give the resident crucial psychiatric and heart medications.
Once again, Edwinola promised to retrain its workers to make sure the problems didn’t happen again, records state.
For Theodore Archer, 91, who is suing the home, learning that the facility had been warned twice before his wife’s death to pay better attention to residents’ health has made his loneliness even more difficult.
“Miss her? God, yes,’’ Archer said. “I guess it’ll be a long time missing her till I go.’
Protecting yourself and your loved ones
If you are considering an assisted-living facility for yourself or a relative:
• Consult your doctor. If your relative is suffering from the infirmities of aging, make sure they are able to live at an ALF. ALF residents must be able to perform most of their activities of daily living — such as going to the toilet, dressing, and getting around — with only minimal assistance. An elder who is bed-bound, for example, cannot live safely in an ALF.
• Consider a facility that’s close to family and trusted friends. Advocates say ALF residents who are visited regularly by involved and inquisitive family members generally receive better care. Residents who are isolated from family, and who do not have strong-voiced advocates, are more likely to be overlooked.
• Seek help from a financial advisor. If you do not have long-term care insurance, you won’t want to deplete your savings too quickly, because facilities that accept rent from government insurance programs, such as Medicaid, as their only source of revenue often operate on the thinnest of margins. Look for ways to stretch out your savings so you can live in the home best suited to meet your needs.
If you are choosing among different assisted-living facilities:
• Consult the Long-term Care Ombudsman Council in your community. The councils maintain several resources that are available to the public.
• Review the Agency for Health Care Administration’s website at www.ahca.state.fl.us. The results of the agency’s inspections, once every two years, complaint investigations and other resources are available to the public.
• Visit the facilities that interest you at different times of day. A home that seems cool in the evening may be hot at mid-afternoon. Tour the entire facility, not just the lobby. Look inside residents’ rooms. Pay attention to all your senses, especially smell.
• Reach out to the facility’s family or residents’ council. Attend a residents’ council meeting, if you can, and ask lots of questions.
• Check the ALF’s activities calendar, and ask to observe daily activities. Boredom and inactivity are unhealthy for elders, so look for a facility that will keep you or your loved one busy and entertained.
• Visit at mealtime, and not just one meal. Records show ALFs often are faulted for having menus with a variety of healthy, enticing options — and then cooking meals that don’t match the menu. Be sure that the facility you pick is capable of providing a diet that meets your needs, such as offerings for people with diabetes. A Sunday night visit is recommended, because Sunday evening meals often are the most overlooked by facility staff, records show.
• Talk to a lawyer before signing any contracts. If you sign a contract that allows only binding arbitration when something goes terribly wrong — such as a death or disabling injury — you will lose the right to sue, and you could forgo significant damages that you might otherwise be entitled to.
• Ask to see the résumé of the home’s administrator and director of resident services, who may be the only manager on site with a degree or professional experience.
When you move in to an assisted-living facility:
• Know and document the names of every caregiver who works with you or your loved one. Don’t be afraid to ask for names and birth dates, and vet the people who spend the most time with them. Caregivers often are the difference between life and death if your loved one experiences a severe fall or other healthcare emergency.
Check the details of your loved one’s medications at least once monthly. Does the medication match the prescription? Is the dosage accurate? Read the fine print. If your loved one is taking several prescriptions, are there any interactions that may prove lethal? Is your loved one being prescribed medications by a doctor other than your family physician? If so, what do you know about that doctor?
What you should you do if something goes wrong:
• If your loved one dies at an ALF, and you suspect the death was not natural, request an autopsy by the county medical examiner.
Be sure to document everything. Your observations and impressions may be helpful to authorities who investigate what happened.
You have a right to call or write authorities if you suspect an ALF resident has experienced abuse, neglect or financial exploitation. The state Department of Children & Families investigates all such reports and can be reached at 800-96 ABUSE. The Agency for Health Care Administration also investigates reports of maltreatment, and can be reached at 888-419-3456.
You also can report concerns of improper care to the Long-term Care Ombudsman Council in your area.
BY CAROL MARBIN MILLER, MICHAEL SALLAH AND ROB BARRY
CMARBIN@MIAMIHERALD.COM
- Spencer Kuvin
Cohen & Kuvin, LLC
http://www.cohenkuvin.com/
stk@cohenkuvin.com
Monday, April 25, 2011
Breaking News Alert
We provide these breaking news alerts to ensure consumers are protected and educated in hopes that this information will keep you safe and aware of threats to your families’ well-being.
National Highway Transportation Safety Administration’s (NHTSA) Office of Defect Investigation (ODI) and Consumer Product Safety Commission (CPSC) announce new Recalls & Alerts:
Toyota Airbag Sensor Malfunction Recall
Toyota has issued a recall of approximately 307,000 vehicles due to a defect affecting the frontal airbag sensors. Certain 2008 Highlander, Highlander Hybrid and 2007-2008 RAV4 SUVs may contain a malfunction in the airbag sensors designed to detect the vehicle roll angle. This can prevent the roll detection system from properly activating, significantly increasing the risk of enhanced injury during a crash.
The recall is expected to begin in mid-May 2011 and dealers will inspect the vehicle and perform the necessary service free of charge. Owners may contact Toyota directly at 1-800-331-4331. Additional details can also be found by referencing NHTSA CAMPAIGN ID Number: 11V245000.
Salt and Snow Intrusion Steer Nissan Recall
Nissan has issued a recall of approximately 195,000 vehicles due to a defect affecting the steering column. Certain 1997-2003 Pathfinder and 1993-2004 Infiniti QX4 vehicles that are exposed to snow, water and salt may be at risk for a steering column malfunction, caused by these elements entering the assembly location hole in the upper strut housing. This snow/water and salt intrusion may result in corrosion of the strut tower housing causing cracks, and a potential break in the steering column. These factors can lead to loss of steering control, significantly increasing the risk of a crash.
The recall is expected to begin on or before May 16, 2011 and dealers will inspect the vehicle and perform the necessary service free of charge. Owners may contact Nissan directly at 1-800-647-7261. Additional details can also be found by referencing NHTSA CAMPAIGN ID Number: 11V244000.
Owners are encouraged to contact the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration’s Vehicle Safety Hotline at 1-888-327-4236 (TTY 1-800-424-9153) or go to www.safercar.gov, with any questions or concerns surrounding these or any other recalls or safety campaigns.
Kiddieland Trikes and Scooters Recalled for Laceration Hazards
The U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission has issued a recall of two different children’s toys manufactured by Kiddieland Toys Limited due to various laceration hazards.
The first recall involves approximately 9,000 “Disney Princess Plastic Racing Trikes” which pose a laceration hazard due to a plastic castle display and princess figures protruding from the top of the handle bars. The trikes are pink and fuchsia with a purple seat and wheels and "Disney Princess" is printed on the label in front of the trike just below the handlebar. The trikes were sold at Target, JCPenney, Meijer and H.E.B. stores nationwide and on the Web at www.target.com from January 2009 through April 2011 for about $50.
Consumers should immediately take the trikes away from children and contact Kiddieland for a free replacement handlebar with an enclosed rotating display. For additional information, contact Kiddieland at (800) 430-5307 anytime, or visit the firm's website at www.kiddieland.com.hk
The second recall involves approximately 16,000 Kiddieland “Lights and Sounds” three-wheeled scooters including a red Spiderman, a blue Thomas & Friends™ and a pink girl’s scooter. A child’s finger can get caught in the hinge mechanism between the steering column and the platform, posing a laceration hazard. The scooters have buttons on the handle that play music and sounds. “Kiddieland” is molded on the back of the steering mechanism. Spiderman or Thomas & Friends™ are found on the steering mechanism and platform. The girl’s model has butterflies on the platform. The scooters were sold at Toys R Us and JCPenney from January 2009 through February 2011 for about $40.
Consumers should immediately take the recalled scooters away from children and contact Kiddieland for a free repair kit. For additional information, contact Kiddieland toll-free at (800) 430-5307 or visit the firm's website at www.kiddieland.com.hk
To report a dangerous product or a product-related injury, call CPSC's Hotline at (800) 638-2772 or CPSC's teletypewriter at (800) 638-8270. Consumers are encouraged to obtain more details on recalls and general safety information by logging on to CPSC's Web site at http://www.cpsc.gov/.
Cohen & Kuvin, LLC
Spencer T. Kuvin
stk@cohenkuvin.com
http://www.cohenkuvin.com/
National Highway Transportation Safety Administration’s (NHTSA) Office of Defect Investigation (ODI) and Consumer Product Safety Commission (CPSC) announce new Recalls & Alerts:
Toyota Airbag Sensor Malfunction Recall
Toyota has issued a recall of approximately 307,000 vehicles due to a defect affecting the frontal airbag sensors. Certain 2008 Highlander, Highlander Hybrid and 2007-2008 RAV4 SUVs may contain a malfunction in the airbag sensors designed to detect the vehicle roll angle. This can prevent the roll detection system from properly activating, significantly increasing the risk of enhanced injury during a crash.
The recall is expected to begin in mid-May 2011 and dealers will inspect the vehicle and perform the necessary service free of charge. Owners may contact Toyota directly at 1-800-331-4331. Additional details can also be found by referencing NHTSA CAMPAIGN ID Number: 11V245000.
Salt and Snow Intrusion Steer Nissan Recall
Nissan has issued a recall of approximately 195,000 vehicles due to a defect affecting the steering column. Certain 1997-2003 Pathfinder and 1993-2004 Infiniti QX4 vehicles that are exposed to snow, water and salt may be at risk for a steering column malfunction, caused by these elements entering the assembly location hole in the upper strut housing. This snow/water and salt intrusion may result in corrosion of the strut tower housing causing cracks, and a potential break in the steering column. These factors can lead to loss of steering control, significantly increasing the risk of a crash.
The recall is expected to begin on or before May 16, 2011 and dealers will inspect the vehicle and perform the necessary service free of charge. Owners may contact Nissan directly at 1-800-647-7261. Additional details can also be found by referencing NHTSA CAMPAIGN ID Number: 11V244000.
Owners are encouraged to contact the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration’s Vehicle Safety Hotline at 1-888-327-4236 (TTY 1-800-424-9153) or go to www.safercar.gov, with any questions or concerns surrounding these or any other recalls or safety campaigns.
Kiddieland Trikes and Scooters Recalled for Laceration Hazards
The U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission has issued a recall of two different children’s toys manufactured by Kiddieland Toys Limited due to various laceration hazards.
The first recall involves approximately 9,000 “Disney Princess Plastic Racing Trikes” which pose a laceration hazard due to a plastic castle display and princess figures protruding from the top of the handle bars. The trikes are pink and fuchsia with a purple seat and wheels and "Disney Princess" is printed on the label in front of the trike just below the handlebar. The trikes were sold at Target, JCPenney, Meijer and H.E.B. stores nationwide and on the Web at www.target.com from January 2009 through April 2011 for about $50.
Consumers should immediately take the trikes away from children and contact Kiddieland for a free replacement handlebar with an enclosed rotating display. For additional information, contact Kiddieland at (800) 430-5307 anytime, or visit the firm's website at www.kiddieland.com.hk
The second recall involves approximately 16,000 Kiddieland “Lights and Sounds” three-wheeled scooters including a red Spiderman, a blue Thomas & Friends™ and a pink girl’s scooter. A child’s finger can get caught in the hinge mechanism between the steering column and the platform, posing a laceration hazard. The scooters have buttons on the handle that play music and sounds. “Kiddieland” is molded on the back of the steering mechanism. Spiderman or Thomas & Friends™ are found on the steering mechanism and platform. The girl’s model has butterflies on the platform. The scooters were sold at Toys R Us and JCPenney from January 2009 through February 2011 for about $40.
Consumers should immediately take the recalled scooters away from children and contact Kiddieland for a free repair kit. For additional information, contact Kiddieland toll-free at (800) 430-5307 or visit the firm's website at www.kiddieland.com.hk
To report a dangerous product or a product-related injury, call CPSC's Hotline at (800) 638-2772 or CPSC's teletypewriter at (800) 638-8270. Consumers are encouraged to obtain more details on recalls and general safety information by logging on to CPSC's Web site at http://www.cpsc.gov/.
Cohen & Kuvin, LLC
Spencer T. Kuvin
stk@cohenkuvin.com
http://www.cohenkuvin.com/
Labels:
Attorney,
cohen kuvin,
lawyer,
product liability,
Spencer Kuvin
Monday, April 18, 2011
Breaking News Alert
We provide these breaking news alerts to ensure consumers are protected and educated in hopes that this information will keep you safe and aware of threats to your families’ well-being.
National Highway Transportation Safety Administration’s (NHTSA) Office of Defect Investigation (ODI) and Consumer Product Safety Commission (CPSC) announce new Recalls & Alerts:
Ford Inadvertent Air Bag Recall
Ford has issued a recall of approximately 1,325,000 vehicles due to a defect affecting the front airbags. The clockspring jumper wiring in certain 2004-2006 F-150 pick up trucks and 2006 Lincoln Mark LT vehicles may become chafed, creating a short circuit which can lead to the driver front airbags inadvertently deploying. These circumstances can significantly increase the risk of an accident, loss of vehicle control and enhanced injures.
The recall is expected to begin on or before May 9, 2011 and dealers will inspect the vehicle and perform the necessary service free of charge. Owners may contact Ford directly at 1-866-436-7332 and reference Ford’s recall campaign number 11S18. Additional details can also be found by referencing NHTSA CAMPAIGN ID Number: 11V107000
MV Agusta Motorcycle Recall
MV Agusta has issued a recall of approximately 200 F4 motorcycles due to a defect affecting the rear subframe. Certain 2010 bikes may have been manufactured with weak fixture points which can result in the subframe cracking or failing. The stability of the rider and any passenger is significantly jeopardized, if this occurs, especially while the bike is in operation.
The recall is expected to begin in April 2011 and dealers will inspect the vehicle and perform the necessary service free of charge. Owners may contact MV Agusta directly at 1-215-830-3300. Additional details can also be found by referencing NHTSA CAMPAIGN ID Number: 11V232000
Owners are encouraged to contact the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration’s Vehicle Safety Hotline at 1-888-327-4236 (TTY 1-800-424-9153) or go to www.safercar.gov, with any questions or concerns surrounding these or any other recalls or safety campaigns.
Spencer T. Kuvin
Cohen & Kuvin, LLC
stk@cohenkuvin.com
http://www.cohenkuvin.com/
National Highway Transportation Safety Administration’s (NHTSA) Office of Defect Investigation (ODI) and Consumer Product Safety Commission (CPSC) announce new Recalls & Alerts:
Ford Inadvertent Air Bag Recall
Ford has issued a recall of approximately 1,325,000 vehicles due to a defect affecting the front airbags. The clockspring jumper wiring in certain 2004-2006 F-150 pick up trucks and 2006 Lincoln Mark LT vehicles may become chafed, creating a short circuit which can lead to the driver front airbags inadvertently deploying. These circumstances can significantly increase the risk of an accident, loss of vehicle control and enhanced injures.
The recall is expected to begin on or before May 9, 2011 and dealers will inspect the vehicle and perform the necessary service free of charge. Owners may contact Ford directly at 1-866-436-7332 and reference Ford’s recall campaign number 11S18. Additional details can also be found by referencing NHTSA CAMPAIGN ID Number: 11V107000
MV Agusta Motorcycle Recall
MV Agusta has issued a recall of approximately 200 F4 motorcycles due to a defect affecting the rear subframe. Certain 2010 bikes may have been manufactured with weak fixture points which can result in the subframe cracking or failing. The stability of the rider and any passenger is significantly jeopardized, if this occurs, especially while the bike is in operation.
The recall is expected to begin in April 2011 and dealers will inspect the vehicle and perform the necessary service free of charge. Owners may contact MV Agusta directly at 1-215-830-3300. Additional details can also be found by referencing NHTSA CAMPAIGN ID Number: 11V232000
Owners are encouraged to contact the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration’s Vehicle Safety Hotline at 1-888-327-4236 (TTY 1-800-424-9153) or go to www.safercar.gov, with any questions or concerns surrounding these or any other recalls or safety campaigns.
Spencer T. Kuvin
Cohen & Kuvin, LLC
stk@cohenkuvin.com
http://www.cohenkuvin.com/
Labels:
Attorney,
cohen kuvin,
delray beach,
lawsuit,
lawyer,
Spencer Kuvin
Monday, April 11, 2011
Cohen & Kuvin - Breaking News Alert
We provide these breaking news alerts to ensure consumers are protected and educated in hopes that this information will keep you safe and aware of threats to your families’ well-being.
National Highway Transportation Safety Administration’s (NHTSA) Office of Defect Investigation (ODI) and Consumer Product Safety Commission (CPSC) announce new Recalls & Alerts:
Steering Wheel Separation Recall
General Motors has issued a recall of approximately 2,100 Chevrolet Cruze vehicles for a manufacturing defect affecting the steering column. The steering wheel in certain 2011 cars may have been improperly fastened and can detach from the steering column. If this occurs, the driver may lose the ability to steer the vehicle, significantly increasing the risk of a crash.
The recall is expected to begin on or before April 8, 2011 and dealers will inspect the vehicle and perform the necessary service free of charge. Owners may contact Chevrolet directly at 1-800-630-2438 or visit www.gmownercenter.com. Additional details can also be found by referencing NHTSA CAMPAIGN ID Number: 11V221000
Mercedes Cruise Control Malfunction
Mercedes-Benz has issued a recall of approximately 136,000 vehicles for a defect affecting the cruise control system. Certain 2000-2002 M-Class and 2000-2004 M-Class AMG vehicles may not automatically disengage the cruise control when the brake pedal is tapped. Other methods for disengaging such as using the cruise control stalk are not affected and will remain an option for deceleration in the event the brake does not disengage. A delay or difficulty disengaging the cruise control can increase the risk of crash.
The recall is expected to begin in September 2011 and dealers will inspect the vehicle and perform the necessary service free of charge. Owners may contact Mercedes-Benz directly at 1-800-367-6372. Additional details can also be found by referencing NHTSA CAMPAIGN ID Number: 11V208000
Reverse Controls Result in Matrix Motorcycle Recall
E-Ton is recalling approximately 25,000 Matrix motorcycles for a defect affecting the ignition switch and failure to comply with the federal motor vehicle safety standard no. 213 regarding "motorcycle controls and displays." The following models are included in this recall: Model year 1999-2010 50CC and 150CC, Beamer I, Beamer II, Beamer III, and model year 2007-2010 50CC and 150CC Matrix motorcycles. The engine on/off switch should be located on the right side handlebar and the high/low beam light switch should be located on the left handlebar. These switch locations are reversed on the models listed above. The reverse locations may cause the driver to get confused while operating the bike, increasing the risk of a crash.
The recall schedule has not been set, but owners will be notified, and dealers will inspect the vehicle and perform the necessary service free of charge. Owners may contact E-Ton directly at 1-866-224-3318. Additional details can also be found by referencing NHTSA CAMPAIGN ID Number: 11V189000
Owners are encouraged to contact the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration’s Vehicle Safety Hotline at 1-888-327-4236 (TTY 1-800-424-9153) or go to www.safercar.gov, with any questions or concerns surrounding these or any other recalls or safety campaigns.
Pampers Pacifiers Recalled For Choking Hazard
The U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission has issued a recall of approximately 29,000 Pampers Natural Stages Infant Ortho and Bulb Pacifiers. The pacifiers fail to meet federal safety standards and pose a choking hazard for young children.
The pacifiers come in yellow, pink or blue colors and "Stage 1" and "Ortho" or "Bulb" are printed on the package. The recalled pacifiers have an oval-shaped mouth guard and "Pampers" molded on to the handle side of the mouth guard. The product comes two per package and were sold in retail stores nationwide from April 2010 through February 2011 for about $6.
Consumers should immediately take the recalled pacifiers away from infants and contact Key Baby for instructions on returning the product for a full refund or $10 coupon toward the purchase of any Pampers® Natural Stages products. For additional information, contact Key Baby toll-free at (800) 447-1224 anytime, or visit the company's web site at www.key-baby.com
To report a dangerous product or a product-related injury, call CPSC's Hotline at (800) 638-2772 or CPSC's teletypewriter at (800) 638-8270. Consumers are encouraged to obtain more details on recalls and general safety information by logging on to CPSC's Web site at http://www.cpsc.gov/.
Spencer T. Kuvin
Cohen & Kuvin, LLC
stk@cohenkuvin.com
http://www.cohenkuvin.com/
National Highway Transportation Safety Administration’s (NHTSA) Office of Defect Investigation (ODI) and Consumer Product Safety Commission (CPSC) announce new Recalls & Alerts:
Steering Wheel Separation Recall
General Motors has issued a recall of approximately 2,100 Chevrolet Cruze vehicles for a manufacturing defect affecting the steering column. The steering wheel in certain 2011 cars may have been improperly fastened and can detach from the steering column. If this occurs, the driver may lose the ability to steer the vehicle, significantly increasing the risk of a crash.
The recall is expected to begin on or before April 8, 2011 and dealers will inspect the vehicle and perform the necessary service free of charge. Owners may contact Chevrolet directly at 1-800-630-2438 or visit www.gmownercenter.com. Additional details can also be found by referencing NHTSA CAMPAIGN ID Number: 11V221000
Mercedes Cruise Control Malfunction
Mercedes-Benz has issued a recall of approximately 136,000 vehicles for a defect affecting the cruise control system. Certain 2000-2002 M-Class and 2000-2004 M-Class AMG vehicles may not automatically disengage the cruise control when the brake pedal is tapped. Other methods for disengaging such as using the cruise control stalk are not affected and will remain an option for deceleration in the event the brake does not disengage. A delay or difficulty disengaging the cruise control can increase the risk of crash.
The recall is expected to begin in September 2011 and dealers will inspect the vehicle and perform the necessary service free of charge. Owners may contact Mercedes-Benz directly at 1-800-367-6372. Additional details can also be found by referencing NHTSA CAMPAIGN ID Number: 11V208000
Reverse Controls Result in Matrix Motorcycle Recall
E-Ton is recalling approximately 25,000 Matrix motorcycles for a defect affecting the ignition switch and failure to comply with the federal motor vehicle safety standard no. 213 regarding "motorcycle controls and displays." The following models are included in this recall: Model year 1999-2010 50CC and 150CC, Beamer I, Beamer II, Beamer III, and model year 2007-2010 50CC and 150CC Matrix motorcycles. The engine on/off switch should be located on the right side handlebar and the high/low beam light switch should be located on the left handlebar. These switch locations are reversed on the models listed above. The reverse locations may cause the driver to get confused while operating the bike, increasing the risk of a crash.
The recall schedule has not been set, but owners will be notified, and dealers will inspect the vehicle and perform the necessary service free of charge. Owners may contact E-Ton directly at 1-866-224-3318. Additional details can also be found by referencing NHTSA CAMPAIGN ID Number: 11V189000
Owners are encouraged to contact the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration’s Vehicle Safety Hotline at 1-888-327-4236 (TTY 1-800-424-9153) or go to www.safercar.gov, with any questions or concerns surrounding these or any other recalls or safety campaigns.
Pampers Pacifiers Recalled For Choking Hazard
The U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission has issued a recall of approximately 29,000 Pampers Natural Stages Infant Ortho and Bulb Pacifiers. The pacifiers fail to meet federal safety standards and pose a choking hazard for young children.
The pacifiers come in yellow, pink or blue colors and "Stage 1" and "Ortho" or "Bulb" are printed on the package. The recalled pacifiers have an oval-shaped mouth guard and "Pampers" molded on to the handle side of the mouth guard. The product comes two per package and were sold in retail stores nationwide from April 2010 through February 2011 for about $6.
Consumers should immediately take the recalled pacifiers away from infants and contact Key Baby for instructions on returning the product for a full refund or $10 coupon toward the purchase of any Pampers® Natural Stages products. For additional information, contact Key Baby toll-free at (800) 447-1224 anytime, or visit the company's web site at www.key-baby.com
To report a dangerous product or a product-related injury, call CPSC's Hotline at (800) 638-2772 or CPSC's teletypewriter at (800) 638-8270. Consumers are encouraged to obtain more details on recalls and general safety information by logging on to CPSC's Web site at http://www.cpsc.gov/.
Spencer T. Kuvin
Cohen & Kuvin, LLC
stk@cohenkuvin.com
http://www.cohenkuvin.com/
Labels:
Attorney,
cohen kuvin,
consumer,
delray beach,
lawsuit,
lawyer,
Spencer Kuvin
Monday, April 04, 2011
Breaking News Alert
We provide these breaking news alerts to ensure consumers are protected and educated in hopes that this information will keep you safe and aware of threats to your families’ well-being.
National Highway Transportation Safety Administration’s (NHTSA) Office of Defect Investigation (ODI) announces new Recalls & Alerts:
Mercedes-Benz Sprinter Seat Belt Safety Recall
Mercedes-Benz has issued a recall of approximately 3,400 Sprinter vehicles due to non-compliance with Federal Motor Vehicle Safety Standards 208 and 209 addressing occupant protection in interior impact and seat belt assemblies respectively. The issue affects 2008-2011 2500 and 3500 vehicles equipped with an optional three seat bench in the passenger compartment. In the event of a crash, the safety belts in these vehicles may not provide the appropriate level of restraint, increasing the risk of injury or death.
The recall is expected to begin during May 2011 and dealers will inspect the vehicle and perform the necessary service free of charge. Owners may contact Mercedes-Benz directly at 843-695-5000. Additional details can also be found by referencing NHTSA CAMPAIGN ID Number: 11V210000
Volkswagen Jetta Fuse Malfunction Recall
Volkswagen has issued a recall of approximately 71,000 brand new Jetta vehicles manufactured between March 2010 and March 2011. This recall is due to a defect affecting the converter box fuse which may also be connected to the signal horn and anti-theft alarm system. The electrical wiring and fuse layout is defectively designed in that a blown fuse may affect the power supply and cause the engine, lighting and wipers system to shut off. These factors can occur without warning while the vehicle is in operation, greatly increasing the risk of crash.
The recall is expected to begin during May 2011 and dealers will inspect the vehicle and perform the necessary service free of charge. Owners may contact Volkswagen directly at 1-800-822-8987. Additional details can also be found by referencing NHTSA CAMPAIGN ID Number: 11V196000.
Volkswagen Toureg Tire Safety Recall
Volkswagen has issued a recall of approximately 256 new Toureg Hybrid vehicles manufactured between July 2, 2010 and February 3, 2011. This recall is due to non-compliance with Federal Motor Vehicle Safety Standard No. 110 because the certification labels on certain vehicles contain incorrect tire pressure information. Incorrect tire pressure information could lead to an owner improperly inflating the vehicle tires which can lead to premature tire wear and increase the risk of crash.
The recall is expected to begin on or before April 29, 2011 and dealers will provide an overlay containing the correct tire pressure information free of charge. Owners may contact Volkswagen directly at 1-800-822-8987. Additional details can also be found by referencing NHTSA CAMPAIGN ID Number: 11V195000.
Minotour School Buses Tire Safety Recall
Daimler Trucks has issued a recall of approximately 526 Thomas Built Minotour School Buses built on Ford and GM Chassis between April 17, 2000 and August 29, 2008. This recall is due to non-compliance with Federal Motor Vehicle Safety Standard No. 110 because the certification labels on certain vehicles contain incorrect tire pressure information. Incorrect tire pressure information could lead to an owner improperly inflating the vehicle tires which can lead to premature tire wear and increase the risk of crash.
The recall is expected to begin on or before May 28, 2011 and dealers will provide an overlay containing the correct tire pressure information free of charge. Owners may contact DTNA directly at 1-800-547-0712 and reference campaign number FL-602 if they wish to replace the label themselves. Additional details can also be found by referencing NHTSA CAMPAIGN ID Number: 11V204000.
Owners are encouraged to contact the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration’s Vehicle Safety Hotline at 1-888-327-4236 (TTY 1-800-424-9153) or go to http://www.blogger.com/www.safecar.gov, with any questions or concerns surrounding these or any other recalls or safety campaigns.
- Spencer T. Kuvin
Cohen & Kuvin, LLC
561-665-8020
stk@cohenkuvin.com
http://www.cohenkuvin.com/
National Highway Transportation Safety Administration’s (NHTSA) Office of Defect Investigation (ODI) announces new Recalls & Alerts:
Mercedes-Benz Sprinter Seat Belt Safety Recall
Mercedes-Benz has issued a recall of approximately 3,400 Sprinter vehicles due to non-compliance with Federal Motor Vehicle Safety Standards 208 and 209 addressing occupant protection in interior impact and seat belt assemblies respectively. The issue affects 2008-2011 2500 and 3500 vehicles equipped with an optional three seat bench in the passenger compartment. In the event of a crash, the safety belts in these vehicles may not provide the appropriate level of restraint, increasing the risk of injury or death.
The recall is expected to begin during May 2011 and dealers will inspect the vehicle and perform the necessary service free of charge. Owners may contact Mercedes-Benz directly at 843-695-5000. Additional details can also be found by referencing NHTSA CAMPAIGN ID Number: 11V210000
Volkswagen Jetta Fuse Malfunction Recall
Volkswagen has issued a recall of approximately 71,000 brand new Jetta vehicles manufactured between March 2010 and March 2011. This recall is due to a defect affecting the converter box fuse which may also be connected to the signal horn and anti-theft alarm system. The electrical wiring and fuse layout is defectively designed in that a blown fuse may affect the power supply and cause the engine, lighting and wipers system to shut off. These factors can occur without warning while the vehicle is in operation, greatly increasing the risk of crash.
The recall is expected to begin during May 2011 and dealers will inspect the vehicle and perform the necessary service free of charge. Owners may contact Volkswagen directly at 1-800-822-8987. Additional details can also be found by referencing NHTSA CAMPAIGN ID Number: 11V196000.
Volkswagen Toureg Tire Safety Recall
Volkswagen has issued a recall of approximately 256 new Toureg Hybrid vehicles manufactured between July 2, 2010 and February 3, 2011. This recall is due to non-compliance with Federal Motor Vehicle Safety Standard No. 110 because the certification labels on certain vehicles contain incorrect tire pressure information. Incorrect tire pressure information could lead to an owner improperly inflating the vehicle tires which can lead to premature tire wear and increase the risk of crash.
The recall is expected to begin on or before April 29, 2011 and dealers will provide an overlay containing the correct tire pressure information free of charge. Owners may contact Volkswagen directly at 1-800-822-8987. Additional details can also be found by referencing NHTSA CAMPAIGN ID Number: 11V195000.
Minotour School Buses Tire Safety Recall
Daimler Trucks has issued a recall of approximately 526 Thomas Built Minotour School Buses built on Ford and GM Chassis between April 17, 2000 and August 29, 2008. This recall is due to non-compliance with Federal Motor Vehicle Safety Standard No. 110 because the certification labels on certain vehicles contain incorrect tire pressure information. Incorrect tire pressure information could lead to an owner improperly inflating the vehicle tires which can lead to premature tire wear and increase the risk of crash.
The recall is expected to begin on or before May 28, 2011 and dealers will provide an overlay containing the correct tire pressure information free of charge. Owners may contact DTNA directly at 1-800-547-0712 and reference campaign number FL-602 if they wish to replace the label themselves. Additional details can also be found by referencing NHTSA CAMPAIGN ID Number: 11V204000.
Owners are encouraged to contact the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration’s Vehicle Safety Hotline at 1-888-327-4236 (TTY 1-800-424-9153) or go to http://www.blogger.com/www.safecar.gov, with any questions or concerns surrounding these or any other recalls or safety campaigns.
- Spencer T. Kuvin
Cohen & Kuvin, LLC
561-665-8020
stk@cohenkuvin.com
http://www.cohenkuvin.com/
Labels:
Attorney,
cohen kuvin,
crib death,
delray beach,
lawyer,
NHTSA,
Spencer Kuvin
Monday, March 28, 2011
Toyota Tire Pressure & Honda Odyssey Window Defect
Breaking News Alert
We provide these breaking news alerts to ensure consumers are protected and educated in hopes that this information will keep you safe and aware of threats to your families’ well-being.
National Highway Transportation Safety Administration’s (NHTSA) Office of Defect Investigation (ODI) and Consumer Product Safety Commission (CPSC) announce new Recalls & Alerts:
Toyota Tire Pressure Detection Defect
Toyota has issued a recall of approximately 1,400 vehicles for failing to comply with federal motor safety standard no. 138 regarding tire pressure monitoring systems. Certain 2011 FJ Cruiser and 2009-2011 Tundra vehicles may not have been properly calibrated preventing a low tire pressure warning from illuminating if the tire pressure is too low. Drivers will not receive a warning from the tire pressuring monitor that one or more tires are underinflated increasing the risk that a vehicle will be driven with one or more underinflated tires and increasing the risk of a tire failure that may lead to a crash.
The recall is expected to begin sometime in April 2011, and dealers will inspect the vehicle and perform the necessary service free of charge. Owners may contact Toyota directly at 1-800-444-1074. Additional details can also be found by referencing NHTSA CAMPAIGN ID Number: 11V185000
Honda Odyssey Window Presents Clear Concern
Honda has issued a recall of approximately 2,800 new vehicles for a defect affecting the driver and front passenger door power windows. Certain 2011 Honda Odyssey vehicles may experience a failure in which the window may come off the track causing the window to become inoperative and preventing it from being rolled up or down or causing it to drop into the door. If this occurs, the window may shatter into the passenger cabin increasing the risk of injury to the vehicle occupants.
The recall is expected to begin on or before April 51, 2011, and dealers will inspect the vehicle and perform the necessary service free of charge. Owners may contact Honda directly at 1-800-999-1009 and reference Honda’s safety recall no.R73 & R74. Additional details can also be found by referencing NHTSA CAMPAIGN ID Number: 11V181000
Owners are encouraged to contact the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration’s Vehicle Safety Hotline at 1-888-327-4236 (TTY 1-800-424-9153) or go to www.safercar.gov, with any questions or concerns surrounding these or any other recalls or safety campaigns.
Second Infant Death Prompts Second Announcement of Crib Recall
The U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission is re-announcing the 2008 recall of more than 985,000 drop-side cribs with "Crib Trigger Lock and Safety Peg" hardware due to a second infant death. Missing safety pegs can create a situation where the crib's drop-side rail disengages from the track. This can create a hazardous space in which an infant can become entrapped and suffocate.
The cribs were originally recalled in October 2008 after one infant death, but another death of a 7 month old child from Colorado Springs has prompted this additional alert. The crib was purchased secondhand and re-assembled without safety pegs in the bottom tracks."Buying or accepting cribs second hand can be risky," said CPSC Chairman Inez Tenenbaum. "Second hand cribs may not come with all of the necessary parts that are needed to make sure your baby is safe. We urge parents and caregivers to use caution and to be aware that new rules established by CPSC will bring safer cribs to the market this summer."
This announcement includes the following 49 crib models with "Crib Trigger Lock with Safety Peg" drop-side hardware which were sold at major retail stores including Kmart, Target and Walmart between January 1995 and December 2005 (through September 2007 for model 4624) for about $100. Click here for a complete listing of recalled model numbers.
CPSC urges parents and caregivers to immediately stop using cribs that are missing a safety peg on either leg of the drop side and contact Delta to receive a free, easy-to-install repair kit. Call Delta toll-free at (800) 816-5304 or visit the firm's website at www.cribrecallcenter.com to order the free repair kit. Parents and caregivers are encouraged to find a safe, alternative sleep environment for their child until the repair kit, with new safety pegs, is safely installed on the recalled cribs.
To report a dangerous product or a product-related injury, call CPSC's Hotline at (800) 638-2772 or CPSC's teletypewriter at (800) 638-8270. Consumers are encouraged to obtain more details on recalls and general safety information by logging on to CPSC's Web site at http://www.cpsc.gov/.
Spencer T. Kuvin
Cohen & Kuvin, LLC
561-665-8020
http://www.cohenkuvin.com/
stk@cohenkuvin.com
We provide these breaking news alerts to ensure consumers are protected and educated in hopes that this information will keep you safe and aware of threats to your families’ well-being.
National Highway Transportation Safety Administration’s (NHTSA) Office of Defect Investigation (ODI) and Consumer Product Safety Commission (CPSC) announce new Recalls & Alerts:
Toyota Tire Pressure Detection Defect
Toyota has issued a recall of approximately 1,400 vehicles for failing to comply with federal motor safety standard no. 138 regarding tire pressure monitoring systems. Certain 2011 FJ Cruiser and 2009-2011 Tundra vehicles may not have been properly calibrated preventing a low tire pressure warning from illuminating if the tire pressure is too low. Drivers will not receive a warning from the tire pressuring monitor that one or more tires are underinflated increasing the risk that a vehicle will be driven with one or more underinflated tires and increasing the risk of a tire failure that may lead to a crash.
The recall is expected to begin sometime in April 2011, and dealers will inspect the vehicle and perform the necessary service free of charge. Owners may contact Toyota directly at 1-800-444-1074. Additional details can also be found by referencing NHTSA CAMPAIGN ID Number: 11V185000
Honda Odyssey Window Presents Clear Concern
Honda has issued a recall of approximately 2,800 new vehicles for a defect affecting the driver and front passenger door power windows. Certain 2011 Honda Odyssey vehicles may experience a failure in which the window may come off the track causing the window to become inoperative and preventing it from being rolled up or down or causing it to drop into the door. If this occurs, the window may shatter into the passenger cabin increasing the risk of injury to the vehicle occupants.
The recall is expected to begin on or before April 51, 2011, and dealers will inspect the vehicle and perform the necessary service free of charge. Owners may contact Honda directly at 1-800-999-1009 and reference Honda’s safety recall no.R73 & R74. Additional details can also be found by referencing NHTSA CAMPAIGN ID Number: 11V181000
Owners are encouraged to contact the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration’s Vehicle Safety Hotline at 1-888-327-4236 (TTY 1-800-424-9153) or go to www.safercar.gov, with any questions or concerns surrounding these or any other recalls or safety campaigns.
Second Infant Death Prompts Second Announcement of Crib Recall
The U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission is re-announcing the 2008 recall of more than 985,000 drop-side cribs with "Crib Trigger Lock and Safety Peg" hardware due to a second infant death. Missing safety pegs can create a situation where the crib's drop-side rail disengages from the track. This can create a hazardous space in which an infant can become entrapped and suffocate.
The cribs were originally recalled in October 2008 after one infant death, but another death of a 7 month old child from Colorado Springs has prompted this additional alert. The crib was purchased secondhand and re-assembled without safety pegs in the bottom tracks."Buying or accepting cribs second hand can be risky," said CPSC Chairman Inez Tenenbaum. "Second hand cribs may not come with all of the necessary parts that are needed to make sure your baby is safe. We urge parents and caregivers to use caution and to be aware that new rules established by CPSC will bring safer cribs to the market this summer."
This announcement includes the following 49 crib models with "Crib Trigger Lock with Safety Peg" drop-side hardware which were sold at major retail stores including Kmart, Target and Walmart between January 1995 and December 2005 (through September 2007 for model 4624) for about $100. Click here for a complete listing of recalled model numbers.
CPSC urges parents and caregivers to immediately stop using cribs that are missing a safety peg on either leg of the drop side and contact Delta to receive a free, easy-to-install repair kit. Call Delta toll-free at (800) 816-5304 or visit the firm's website at www.cribrecallcenter.com to order the free repair kit. Parents and caregivers are encouraged to find a safe, alternative sleep environment for their child until the repair kit, with new safety pegs, is safely installed on the recalled cribs.
To report a dangerous product or a product-related injury, call CPSC's Hotline at (800) 638-2772 or CPSC's teletypewriter at (800) 638-8270. Consumers are encouraged to obtain more details on recalls and general safety information by logging on to CPSC's Web site at http://www.cpsc.gov/.
Spencer T. Kuvin
Cohen & Kuvin, LLC
561-665-8020
http://www.cohenkuvin.com/
stk@cohenkuvin.com
Labels:
Attorney,
cohen kuvin,
cpsc,
Honda,
lawyer,
odyssey,
Spencer Kuvin
Sunday, February 20, 2011
Top 10 Animals that Cause Car Wrecks
Check out the Top 10 animals that cause car wrecks.
http://www.satellitedish.org/blog/2011/top-10-animals-that-cause-car-wrecks/
Thank you to Satellite Dish for this information.
We have all had it happen to us… It’s late at night and you are driving on a country road or maybe even a highway in the middle of nowhere and then all of sudden something crosses the road in front of you. A near miss and also a notice to be on the lookout as generally animals travel in packs and that probably wasn’t the last animal you are going to encounter. If all goes well we make it out of a tense driving situation without any roadkill (sorry that is a common term whether you like it or not). It’s far from the intentional slaying of animals utilizing your vehicle, these are accidents where animals just happened to get in the way of your car driving down a perfectly good road. It happens a lot more than you might think. Here are the top 10 animals that cause car wrecks:
Deer. For some reason, deer really do find solace in staring at oncoming headlights. Whether they are aware of the threat or not, they seem to prefer standing firm, getting the full force of the vehicle, even taking lives in the mix. There are many lives lost to these types of accidents due to the size and weight of the animals, with many hooves and antlers causing great injury.
Wild turkey. If you are in one of the many areas that carry wild turkeys, you will find that these animals often find their way into the roadway, especially along the highway. This can be extremely dangerous if you are riding at a high rate of speed and attempt to avoid the animal, however, impact isn’t going to be as dangerous as with deer.
Squirrels. There have been commercials mimicking the behaviors of sneaky squirrels that find their way onto the street just as you are passing by. With such small creatures, you often see them only as you advance closer, often leaving you dodging an animal too late and causing many serious car accidents.
Ducks. There are duck crossings everywhere, but unfortunately, not everyone minds them and not all ducks do either. Some ducks can be found astray, while some people may ignore the duck crossing and attempt to go through the cross quickly, often colliding with the animals or flipping the vehicle attempting to avoid collision.
Dogs. There are so many people out there that are great dog lovers, but these friendly creatures can still find themselves led astray by vehicles that lead them elsewhere. As so many people find great pals in dogs, they often try their best to avoid hitting a dog, leading to many accidents.
Cats. There is a similarity between dogs and cats, and that is the love for each by so many. With cats, they are typically quicker, but end up sitting their lazy butts on the street as cars try to go by. In many cases, however, people aren’t given fair warning as cats love to dart out quickly, leading to accidents of all severity.
Birds. While it isn’t as common, there have been many car accidents associated with birds flying upon the windshield or into the windshield, blocking vision and causing a wreck. This is a very dangerous accident, especially if the driver’s vision is impaired by the animal.
Raccoons. There are many areas that are prominent with raccoons that seem to have the same love for the street as many other animals, sometimes finding their way in line with an oncoming animal. For so many people who find these animals to be cute and loving, they often try their best to avoid hitting them, causing an accident instead.
Bunnies. Yes, bunnies, not rabbits, because when they are on the road, everyone is yelling “don’t hit the bunny!” Unfortunately as you are trying not to hit the bunny, there are other vehicles on the road that can crash into you unaware of what you are doing.
Opossum. Opossums are blind naturally, giving them keen hearing but poor ability to navigate around safely when it comes to roadways. With roads often going off into wooded areas and sections, it is easy to find these animals on the road, often causing accidents as people avoid hitting them.
Whether you accidentally hit the animal or crash avoiding the animal, these animals are the most dangerous animals when it comes to car accidents. Hey, let’s be careful on the roads out there!
- Spencer T. Kuvin
Cohen & Kuvin, LLC
stk@cohenkuvin.com
http://www.cohenkuvin.com/
561-665-8020
http://www.satellitedish.org/blog/2011/top-10-animals-that-cause-car-wrecks/
Thank you to Satellite Dish for this information.
We have all had it happen to us… It’s late at night and you are driving on a country road or maybe even a highway in the middle of nowhere and then all of sudden something crosses the road in front of you. A near miss and also a notice to be on the lookout as generally animals travel in packs and that probably wasn’t the last animal you are going to encounter. If all goes well we make it out of a tense driving situation without any roadkill (sorry that is a common term whether you like it or not). It’s far from the intentional slaying of animals utilizing your vehicle, these are accidents where animals just happened to get in the way of your car driving down a perfectly good road. It happens a lot more than you might think. Here are the top 10 animals that cause car wrecks:
Deer. For some reason, deer really do find solace in staring at oncoming headlights. Whether they are aware of the threat or not, they seem to prefer standing firm, getting the full force of the vehicle, even taking lives in the mix. There are many lives lost to these types of accidents due to the size and weight of the animals, with many hooves and antlers causing great injury.
Wild turkey. If you are in one of the many areas that carry wild turkeys, you will find that these animals often find their way into the roadway, especially along the highway. This can be extremely dangerous if you are riding at a high rate of speed and attempt to avoid the animal, however, impact isn’t going to be as dangerous as with deer.
Squirrels. There have been commercials mimicking the behaviors of sneaky squirrels that find their way onto the street just as you are passing by. With such small creatures, you often see them only as you advance closer, often leaving you dodging an animal too late and causing many serious car accidents.
Ducks. There are duck crossings everywhere, but unfortunately, not everyone minds them and not all ducks do either. Some ducks can be found astray, while some people may ignore the duck crossing and attempt to go through the cross quickly, often colliding with the animals or flipping the vehicle attempting to avoid collision.
Dogs. There are so many people out there that are great dog lovers, but these friendly creatures can still find themselves led astray by vehicles that lead them elsewhere. As so many people find great pals in dogs, they often try their best to avoid hitting a dog, leading to many accidents.
Cats. There is a similarity between dogs and cats, and that is the love for each by so many. With cats, they are typically quicker, but end up sitting their lazy butts on the street as cars try to go by. In many cases, however, people aren’t given fair warning as cats love to dart out quickly, leading to accidents of all severity.
Birds. While it isn’t as common, there have been many car accidents associated with birds flying upon the windshield or into the windshield, blocking vision and causing a wreck. This is a very dangerous accident, especially if the driver’s vision is impaired by the animal.
Raccoons. There are many areas that are prominent with raccoons that seem to have the same love for the street as many other animals, sometimes finding their way in line with an oncoming animal. For so many people who find these animals to be cute and loving, they often try their best to avoid hitting them, causing an accident instead.
Bunnies. Yes, bunnies, not rabbits, because when they are on the road, everyone is yelling “don’t hit the bunny!” Unfortunately as you are trying not to hit the bunny, there are other vehicles on the road that can crash into you unaware of what you are doing.
Opossum. Opossums are blind naturally, giving them keen hearing but poor ability to navigate around safely when it comes to roadways. With roads often going off into wooded areas and sections, it is easy to find these animals on the road, often causing accidents as people avoid hitting them.
Whether you accidentally hit the animal or crash avoiding the animal, these animals are the most dangerous animals when it comes to car accidents. Hey, let’s be careful on the roads out there!
- Spencer T. Kuvin
Cohen & Kuvin, LLC
stk@cohenkuvin.com
http://www.cohenkuvin.com/
561-665-8020
Labels:
animals,
Attorney,
car wrecks,
cohen kuvin,
lawyer,
Spencer Kuvin
Friday, February 11, 2011
Latest News From Cohen & Kuvin
NASA Says Toyota Sudden Acceleration User Error?
After decades of driving vehicles where the gas pedal is located to the right of the brake, drivers still can’t tell the difference. At least that is the general sentiment of NASA scientists, who completed their 10 month investigation of Toyota’s unintended acceleration with the conclusion that there is no evidence that the sudden acceleration was caused by electronic controls. The actual culprits are improperly installed floor mats, sticky pedals and driver error.
According to NHTSA deputy administrator Ron Medford, drivers may have confused the gas and brake pedals, a problem that may account for ‘the vast majority’ of the unintended acceleration incidents the agency investigated. This seems rather suspect considering that the placement of pedals in the vehicle is a standard design. What is not standard is the new electronic throttle control which controls a cars speed using sensors and computer chips to pass commands between the vehicles' gas pedal and the engine. This innovative feature replaces the simple mechanical connection used in older cars. It is clear by the large amount of redactions to the NHTSA report that all of the findings have not been disclosed to the public. It is also very clear that the findings contain blatant shortcomings.
Houston….we have a problem……Are the best and brightest at NASA saying that Americans can’t tell left from right and Toyota’s are safe?
Fourth District Court of Appeal Finds Payday Lending Company’s Contracts Violate Public Policy—Great Victory for Consumer Rights
Florida’s Fourth District Court of Appeal recently held in McKenzie Check Advance v. Betts, 2011 WL 309318 (Fla. 4th DCA Feb. 2, 2011), that the class action bans payday lending companies put in their consumer contracts violate public policy by preventing consumers from vindicating their statutory rights under the Florida Deceptive and Unfair Trade Practices Act and the Florida Civil Remedies for Criminal Practices Act. The payday lending companies, which make their money by charging outrageously (and at one time criminally) high amounts of interest to impoverished people living paycheck to paycheck, have attempted to insulate themselves from class actions because they know that is the only way consumers could realistically challenge the companies’ unfair practices. In a great victory for consumer rights, the Fourth District Court of Appeal removed this protection from payday lenders by holding these class action bans are unenforceable because they violate public policy.
Florida Legislation Proposed to Increase Benefits to Victims of Brain Injury
Chapter 916 of the Florida Statutes provides special care and “forensic services” for mentally ill and mentally deficient criminal defendants. It was the intent of the legislature to provide facilities and programs to treat and train individuals who have been charged with felonies but who are mentally incompetent by reason of mental illness, mental retardation, or autism.
Unfortunately, the statutes do not apply to individuals who are mentally deficient due to traumatic brain injury, a growing “silent epidemic.” Wellington State representative Joseph Abruzzo with the assistance of Palm Beach County Circuit Judge Krista Marx, is attempting to close this loophole by expanding the definition of “mental illness” to include victims with traumatic brain injury.
We applaud Rep. Abruzzo and encourage the legislature to pass his proposed amendments. The traumatically brain injured, whether combat veterans or civilian casualties, often lack the capacity to understand and appreciate the nature of their actions and are certainly entitled to the same benefits as those who are unfortunately born with similar mental deficiencies.
Space Heater Safety Tips
According to the United States Fire Administration, home fires spike during the winter. The risk of home fires increases with the use of supplemental heating, such as space heaters. The U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission has issued the following tips to ensure your home is safely heated. Never place space heaters on rugs or carpets. They should be placed on a flat and level floor in area free from foot traffic and at least three feet from other flammable materials; such as, bedding, drapes and certain furniture. Additionally, never leave a space heater on when you go to sleep and never place a space heater next to a sleeping person. Finally, if you choose to use a kerosene space heater, never mix in gasoline as even small amounts of gasoline mixed with kerosene can increase the risk of fire. As we all know, beautiful, sunny South Florida is not without its cold days. The staff at Cohen & Kuvin, LLC urge everyone to make sure themselves and their relatives up north stay safe this winter.
http://www.cohenkuvin.com/
stk@cohenkuvin.com
Spencer T. Kuvin
Cohen & Kuvin, LLC
stk@cohenkuvin.com
After decades of driving vehicles where the gas pedal is located to the right of the brake, drivers still can’t tell the difference. At least that is the general sentiment of NASA scientists, who completed their 10 month investigation of Toyota’s unintended acceleration with the conclusion that there is no evidence that the sudden acceleration was caused by electronic controls. The actual culprits are improperly installed floor mats, sticky pedals and driver error.
According to NHTSA deputy administrator Ron Medford, drivers may have confused the gas and brake pedals, a problem that may account for ‘the vast majority’ of the unintended acceleration incidents the agency investigated. This seems rather suspect considering that the placement of pedals in the vehicle is a standard design. What is not standard is the new electronic throttle control which controls a cars speed using sensors and computer chips to pass commands between the vehicles' gas pedal and the engine. This innovative feature replaces the simple mechanical connection used in older cars. It is clear by the large amount of redactions to the NHTSA report that all of the findings have not been disclosed to the public. It is also very clear that the findings contain blatant shortcomings.
Houston….we have a problem……Are the best and brightest at NASA saying that Americans can’t tell left from right and Toyota’s are safe?
Fourth District Court of Appeal Finds Payday Lending Company’s Contracts Violate Public Policy—Great Victory for Consumer Rights
Florida’s Fourth District Court of Appeal recently held in McKenzie Check Advance v. Betts, 2011 WL 309318 (Fla. 4th DCA Feb. 2, 2011), that the class action bans payday lending companies put in their consumer contracts violate public policy by preventing consumers from vindicating their statutory rights under the Florida Deceptive and Unfair Trade Practices Act and the Florida Civil Remedies for Criminal Practices Act. The payday lending companies, which make their money by charging outrageously (and at one time criminally) high amounts of interest to impoverished people living paycheck to paycheck, have attempted to insulate themselves from class actions because they know that is the only way consumers could realistically challenge the companies’ unfair practices. In a great victory for consumer rights, the Fourth District Court of Appeal removed this protection from payday lenders by holding these class action bans are unenforceable because they violate public policy.
Florida Legislation Proposed to Increase Benefits to Victims of Brain Injury
Chapter 916 of the Florida Statutes provides special care and “forensic services” for mentally ill and mentally deficient criminal defendants. It was the intent of the legislature to provide facilities and programs to treat and train individuals who have been charged with felonies but who are mentally incompetent by reason of mental illness, mental retardation, or autism.
Unfortunately, the statutes do not apply to individuals who are mentally deficient due to traumatic brain injury, a growing “silent epidemic.” Wellington State representative Joseph Abruzzo with the assistance of Palm Beach County Circuit Judge Krista Marx, is attempting to close this loophole by expanding the definition of “mental illness” to include victims with traumatic brain injury.
We applaud Rep. Abruzzo and encourage the legislature to pass his proposed amendments. The traumatically brain injured, whether combat veterans or civilian casualties, often lack the capacity to understand and appreciate the nature of their actions and are certainly entitled to the same benefits as those who are unfortunately born with similar mental deficiencies.
Space Heater Safety Tips
According to the United States Fire Administration, home fires spike during the winter. The risk of home fires increases with the use of supplemental heating, such as space heaters. The U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission has issued the following tips to ensure your home is safely heated. Never place space heaters on rugs or carpets. They should be placed on a flat and level floor in area free from foot traffic and at least three feet from other flammable materials; such as, bedding, drapes and certain furniture. Additionally, never leave a space heater on when you go to sleep and never place a space heater next to a sleeping person. Finally, if you choose to use a kerosene space heater, never mix in gasoline as even small amounts of gasoline mixed with kerosene can increase the risk of fire. As we all know, beautiful, sunny South Florida is not without its cold days. The staff at Cohen & Kuvin, LLC urge everyone to make sure themselves and their relatives up north stay safe this winter.
http://www.cohenkuvin.com/
stk@cohenkuvin.com
Spencer T. Kuvin
Cohen & Kuvin, LLC
stk@cohenkuvin.com
Why Don't School Buses Have Seatbelts?
Posted by: Cohen & Kuvin
February 09, 2011
Topic: Seatbelt Safety
Every year vehicles are manufactured boasting innovative features and safeguards designed to protect drivers and passengers. Yet, we have seen very little innovation in school bus safety, starting with the absence of seatbelts.
There are a host of studies that claim school buses are one of the safest modes of transportation, so federal law only requires seatbelts in buses under 10,000 pounds. However, 80% of the nations' school bus fleet exceeds that weight limit, and in those cases, the decision to provide seatbelts is up to the individual states.
Current safety standards in schools buses are characterized by compartmentalization, a system of tightly spaced seats covered with 4-inch-thick foam to form a protective bubble. The high seat backs also serve as a buffer to prevent a child from being launched in the air.
The reality is that installing seatbelts in every school bus is extremely cost prohibitive and may pose another hazard of kids whacking each other with the straps. Further, who is to say that fidgety kids will wear the belt, and who is responsible for enforcing them?
According to National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA), an average of 7 school-age passengers are killed in school bus crashes each year. These numbers make it difficult to justify a $117 million per state price tag. In fact, NHTSA said its research suggests that the benefits are "insufficient to justify a federal requirement for mandatory installation of such belts" in larger buses.
Florida is one of 6 states that now requires seat belts or another restraint system that meets federal standards on newer buses and requires passengers to use them. For now, the best tip for a safe ride is encouraging children to practice good safety etiquette on the bus including: remaining seated during the entire bus ride or until the driver says otherwise, keeping aisles clear of backpacks and belongings, talking quietly and politely and always following the driver's directions during an emergency.
- Spencer Kuvin
Cohen & Kuvin, P.A.
http://www.cohenkuvin.com/
stk@cohenkuvin.com
Labels:
Attorney,
cohen kuvin,
lawyer,
school bus,
seatbelts,
Spencer Kuvin
Sunday, September 26, 2010
Article: Potential health threat leads FDA to severely restrict diabetics' use of popular Avandia drug
Potential health threat leads FDA to severely restrict diabetics' use of popular Avandia drug
http://www.palmbeachpost.com/news/state/potential-health-threat-leads-fda-to-severely-restrict-934150.html
Saturday, September 18, 2010
NYTimes: Toyota Settles Over Death of Family in California
From The New York Times:
Toyota Settles Over Death of Family in California
The family, killed when the Lexus sedan they were driving sped out of control, put a national spotlight on the sudden acceleration problems.
http://nyti.ms/92Zcwp
Spencer T. Kuvin
Cohen & Kuvin
561-665-8020
stk@cohenkuvin.com
Toyota Settles Over Death of Family in California
The family, killed when the Lexus sedan they were driving sped out of control, put a national spotlight on the sudden acceleration problems.
http://nyti.ms/92Zcwp
Spencer T. Kuvin
Cohen & Kuvin
561-665-8020
stk@cohenkuvin.com
Tuesday, September 07, 2010
Could Crib Tents Become a Regulated Product?
Reprinted with Permission from Safety Record Blog, Copyright Safety Research Stategies, 2010
On December 27, 2008, the strangulation death of Noah Thompson by a Tots In Mind crib tent became the first to be investigated by the U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission involving this unregulated product. Eighteen months later, in July, the commission and the manufacturer finally announced a recall featuring a repair remedy for the attachment clips.
The Thompson case underscores two continuing weaknesses in the regulatory framework meant to ensure the safety of juvenile products: long gaps between the time when a product is deemed hazardous and a recall, and the difficulty in dealing with baby products that fall outside of the CPSC regulations and are not manufactured to any voluntary or mandatory standard.The CPSC says that the Tots In Mind recall may only be the first action it takes to protect toddlers from the design deficiencies of crib tents.
“CPSC’s Safe Sleep team is reviewing incidents with crib tents to determine the best approach to take with this product class to ensure the safety of young children,” says Scott Wolfson, the CPSC’s Director of its Office of Information and Public Affairs.
In the meantime, Crib Tents continue to be manufactured without regard to established safety standards and marketed under the presumption that they are safe to use with vulnerable populations in situations where adults are absent.
Safety Research & Strategies, which investigated the safety of cribs tents after a Virginia toddler suffered a lifelong brain injury caused by a crib-tent strangulation, turned its findings over to the CPSC. SRS President Sean Kane doesn’t believe that the recall goes far enough.
“We understand that the CPSC is restricted by their regulations in pressing the recall of an unregulated product, but the reality is that there are inherent problems with the design that are not being addressed by the recall.”
The Long Road to a Recall
Thompson was only two years old when he attempted to climb out of a play yard covered by a crib tent – a mesh-covered dome placed over a crib or a play yard to prevent toddlers from climbing out. These mesh domes are affixed to the play yard base with plastic clips. Those intended for use in a crib are all-in-one units that sit inside the crib and attach to the crib’s side rails with a hook and loop system. Parents can place or remove their toddlers in or from the enclosure via a zippered side.
According to the CPSC, Thompson was found “hanging with his neck entrapped between the play yard frame and the metal base rod of the tent that had been partially tied by pieces of nylon rope and partially attached by clips.” The Thompsons had improvised the nylon ties, because “the child was able to pop off the clips,” the CPSC said.
The commission said that it was aware of three other incidents in which children were “able to remove one or more clips and place their necks between the tent and the playard,” but were freed without incident.
The July 15 announcement recalled 20,000 Cozy Indoor Outdoor Portable Playard Tents Plus Cabana Kits, manufactured by Tots In Mind of Salem, N.H., the only U.S. manufacturer of crib tents. The remedy was free replacement clips supplied by Tots In Mind. While Thompson’s death was amply reported by the print and broadcast media, the recall received little coverage.
The year-and-a-half lag between the Thompson death and the recall occurred because the commission was not satisfied with the company’s first proposals for corrective action.
“There were numerous proposals by the company which CPSC staff did not accept due to the concern of the safety of a child being at risk with the proposed corrective action,” Wolfson said “We had to be sure new clipping system addressed the concerns that we had. Repair kits must be submitted to the CPSC, where they are reviewed and approved by CPSC engineers.”
Lengthy investigations and negotiations with the manufacturer– conducted out of the public purview by law – is a continuing source of frustration for safety advocates says Nancy Cowles, executive director of Kids in Danger.
“The CPSC is always pushing to get the company to agree to do a recall, and that’s part of the reason why I think they take so long,” Cowles said. “Also, so much of what the commission does is secret, so we don’t know at what point they had all the information to do a recall.”
The CPSC has other ways to alert the public about dangerous child products, says Don Mays of Consumers Union. He pointed to the commission’s recent move to get out ahead of a March recall on the Infantino Sling Rider and Wendy Bellissimo baby slings.
“There was one product responsible for three infant fatalities, but while negotiating the recall, the CPSC issued a public warning about slings and putting infants in slings, and that put the warning shot out there, instead of waiting for the remedy to be developed. I would like to see more of that, especially if they can’t fast-track a recall.”
The Problem with Crib Tents and Other Unregulated Baby Products
The greater challenge will be addressing the more general hazards associated with crib tents. Like many juvenile products, the crib tent was invented to address a specific problem that may be short-lived, but is very frustrating to parents. Caregivers may regard a crib tent as something that will prevent a fall, while ignorant of the suffocation and strangulation hazards it presents.
About a year before Thompson’s death, another toddler, Nicholas Blanco, suffered a severe and permanent brain injury when he became entrapped and strangled by a Cozy Crib Tent. On October 5, 2007, Blanco was in the crib when one of the fiberglass rods supporting the dome type cover broke and fell into the crib, pinning the boy between the support rod and the side of the crib. His mother discovered her son hanging on the outside of the crib with his neck stuck under the rod of the crib tent.
During the course of its investigation, SRS found stories of an unconfirmed death and other potential tragedies involving crib tents. Parents described the mesh tearing at the seams or at other points or the entire structure collapsing – either pulled down by the toddler or inverting under the weight of a pet. In some cases, the parent discovered the child entangled and was able to free it before an injury occurred.
SRS not only shared these complaints with the CPSC, and wrote and wrote an article on the dangers of crib tents (see Crib Tents: Another Hazard from the World of Unregulated Child Products)
The July recall does not address these hazards and Mays says that juvenile products add-ons – such as crib tents – present “all sorts of compatibility products not foreseen by the manufacturers – it might not fit all units.”
“And when that happens, a child’s safety is at risk. If you talk about sleep environments, it becomes particularly risky,” he says.
Cowles of Kids in Danger had more specific concerns:
“My problem with this recall is that they are saying it’s a safe product and it’s not,” she says. “The commission only counts the incident involving the play yard tent. They have other reported breakages with the crib tents. This recall doesn’t say how many parents complained to Tots in Mind and how many products failed.”
Crib Safety and the CPSC
This year, the CPS began rulemaking on new mandatory standards on cribs that could include provisions covering drop side hardware, mattresses, loose and fragile components, such as crib slats. The new rule may effective ban one of the most common designs: drop-side cribs. The proposal was developed by the commission’s Safe Sleep Team, in conjunction with juvenile products manufacturers and ASTM International, the manufacturing standards-setting body, after studying infant incident and injury data.
CPSC’s Safe Sleep team is also charged with coordinating all crib recalls, developing consumer education on product registration and safe sleep practices.
At last month’s CPSC meeting on Agenda and Priorities in fiscal year 2010, Ami Gadhia, on behalf of Consumers Union, Kids in Danger and the Consumer Federation of America, urged the commission to extend their safe sleep effort to other products such as crib tents, sleep positioners, and infant comforters and pillows.
“We are aware of deaths associated with each of these products, some of which have been recalled due to the hazard they pose to infants,” she said.
Crib tents currently are outside the express outlines of the Consumer Product Safety Improvement Act of 2008, which requires the establishment of standards and certificates of compliance for durable juvenile products that fall into 12 categories: cribs; toddler beds; high chairs, booster chairs, and hook-on chairs; bath seats; gates and other enclosures for confining a child; play yards; stationary activity centers; infant carriers; strollers; walkers; swings; and bassinets and cradles.
But, says Wolfson:
“The staff at the agency is considering another dozen juvenile products to turn into mandatory standards. We have not ruled out that this could be a product we might consider under section 104 of the Act.”
-- for more information on this story you can contact Safety Research & Strategies, 340 Anawan St., Rehoboth, MA 02769 (508) 252-2333
Spencer T. Kuvin
Cohen & Kuvin, LLC
http://www.cohenkuvin.com/
stk@cohenkuvin.com
Labels:
Attorney,
child,
cohen kuvin,
crib death,
lawyer,
product liability,
Spencer Kuvin
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)



